By: Scott Snyder (writer), Greg Capullo (pencils), Jonathan Glapion (inks), Colors (FCO), Richard Starkings & Jimmy Betancourt (letteres), Katie Kubert (assistant editor), Janelle Asselin (associate editor) & Mike Marts (editor)

The Story: Batman has to deal with a new threat from the Court of Owls.

Five Things: 

1. Great art from Capullo/Glapion/FCO.  Greg Capullo lays out his pages so well.  It’s the kind of thing that’s easiest to appreciate when you see comics that aren’t trying to be visually interesting.  Surely Capullo could tell this story with 3-4 widescreen, rectangular panels per page, but that would be boring and Capullo isn’t boring.  It’s nice to see that dedication to craft.  There are also a couple of classic Capullo action panels in this issue.  The one that springs to mind is the one of the bad guy side-kicking Bruce Wayne through the window.  You can just feel the power of that kick. The guy isn’t kicking Bruce, he’s driving right through him.  Then the window is shattering around his body into a bajillion little pieces.  We haven’t seen many of those hyper-detailed Capullo panels thus far in Batman, so it’s nice to see one pop up.  Now, the art isn’t perfect.  There are a few storytelling flaws, like the motorcycle on the train tracks and the point where Bruce gets knives in his shoulders, but overall the art is excellent.  Wonderful inking to retain the dynamism of the pencils and nicely colored as well.

2. A new villain!  Old villains are so boring because we kinda know what they’re capable of and we know they won’t really die.  Villains like Joker and Penguin are just as safe from death as Batman is and it’s impossible to have drama in a story when the only people who can really die are nameless civilians and Bruce’s girlfriends.  So, this new villain is great: He’s got a cool look.  He just thrashed Bruce in a fight.  We don’t really know what he’s up to.  So much is unknown because we’ve not seen Bruce fight this guy before and it’s better that way.

3.  Snyder writes so well.  Have you ever heard a buddy describe a comic as “wordy”?  We all have, but what they usually mean is, “Lots of word by a writer who doesn’t write well.”  Guys who don’t write well can be really painful to read.  So, it’s important to separate the different elements of writing.  There is, “I have a cool idea for a story.”  There is, “I can write clever banter between Spider-Man and Wolverine.”  And, finally, there is, “I can write a long paragraph in a comic slickly enough that fans don’t complain.”  Snyder excels at that final aspect and it gives him creative freedom to engage in exposition or do more to verbally establish a scene.  It’s a handy thing to have in a bag of tricks because not even Capullo could make the first page of this comic tell a story visually…that was all on Snyder.  He’s also smart to get his wordy parts early in the issue when the reader is fresh.

4.  Some non-linear storytelling that might have been unnecessary.  My biggest problem with the issue is that I was a little confused.  The part that stayed with me was the final fight in the tower.  But, I really am not sure how to wedge together the other scenes from the issue.  I clearly could reread it, but I’m often too busy for that and I shouldn’t have to reread to make sense of a comic.  So, even though I liked it, I was a little confused.

5.  This is plenty of Batman for me.  Very much a personal issue and bound to be offensive to some Bat-completists out there, but I don’t need any more Batman in my life than this series.  I’m reading this and enjoying it and don’t remotely feel like I’m missing out because I’m not reading any of the other Bat-titles at DC.  That’s not to say the other titles aren’t good (many folks say they are), but you’ll be fine if you just read this one.

Conclusion: A little confusing in places, but Snyder and Capullo are so good that they can just push through those weaker parts and still make you want to read more.  Love watching Batman taking on a new villain rather than these dusty old rogues that he’s fought a million times before.

Grade: B

– Dean Stell

Follow Dean on Twitter.

Follow WCBR on Twitter and Facebook.

Grade

Conclusion