
By: Kyle Higgins (writer), Eddy Barrows (penciller), JP Mayer & Paulo Siqueira (inkers), Rod Reis (colorist)
The Story: Someday, this antiquated, second-rate circus will all be yours.
The Review: Keeping up relationships with people takes work. You have to put in the effort to stay up-to-date with their lives, lend them a hand when they need favors, and be sympathetic and open to their needs. Of course, we live in a Facebook world, where often all that’s needed to stay in touch with someone is to press “Like” when they post some semi-witty status update about how eating instant noodles for dinner is a metaphor for a drained bank account, FML.
Obligatory as that “Like” may be, it is still an obligation you have to fulfill if you have even a modicum of interest in keeping in touch with that person. It’s one thing for Dick to retain his connections to his circus family, but that means mutual attachment, which in turn means he has some responsibilities towards them. Higgins brought in an interesting new avenue to Dick’s life, but how he’ll play this for long-term continuity value is crucial.
A lot of what we see so far sticks pretty close to the cliché or predictable, most especially the sparks flying between Dick and former circus gal pal Raya. There, you basically have the typical plot of “man runs into the girl-next-door of his youth; past and present collide; heart rending ensues.” You have to take most of this for granted since about the only thing you know about Dick and Raya’s past relationship is that she hated his taste in clothes then, and still does.
Dick’s interaction with the elderly Mr. Haly (of Haly’s Circus fame) offers more fertile ground. After all, before Bruce Wayne stepped in as the former boy wonder’s benefactor, the most natural choice to be Dick’s father figure would have been the man who patronized nearly his whole childhood. Again, Higgins forces us to assume too much about this quasi-father-son relationship, as Mr. Haly’s exact attachment to Dick remains vague at best.
Mr. Haly insists to his dying breath that the circus holds major secrets, which, if true, could turn out a groundbreaking story for Dick. While his circus background makes a core element of his character, the details about that pre-Robin period of his life have always been obscure. Higgins has now taken on the burden of not only telling that story, but making it a substantial part of Nightwing’s new continuity—no easy task.
In the meantime, Dick still has the assassin with the X-23 blades (and the eye-rolling name of Saiko) hot on his tail. At this point, Saiko hasn’t really established much of a reason for his presence. At first glance, you’d think his beef with Dick is personal, but as the issue progresses, he merely repeats his mantra of Dick being the “fiercest killer” in Gotham without elaboration. As a result, he seems only a convenient method of bringing some immediate action to the title.
Barrows delivers pretty lively action, getting Dick flipping, leaping, and dodging all over the page, sometimes silhouetting several times in one panel. But Barrows isn’t the most inspired artist; in one panel on page three, he draws Nightwing kicking Saiko upside the chin (a jerk of blood spurting out through Saiko’s face mask somehow), and on page seventeen, we have essentially the very same panel.
Conclusion: Some interesting seed ideas, but still a toss-up as to whether any of them will really stick. Higgins moves a bit too fast on the present story, leaving some necessary exposition on the shelf.
Grade: C+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Dang it, the old man’s already in the final stages of terminal illness. He doesn’t have to get worked over by an assassin on top of it.
Grade
Conclusion