
By: Ed Brubaker & Marc Andreyko (writers), Chris Samnee (art), Bettie Breitweiser (colors), Joe Caramagna (letters), John Denning (assistant editor) & Lauren Sankovitch (editor)
The Story: Bucky is now the Winter Soldier.
Five things:
1. Chris Samnee is just incredible! – I hate to say someone’s art is “the best” because “the best” is so subjective. But, Chris Samnee is squarely in that mythical “top 10” of comic artists who are capable of doing a monthly comic book. What’s so impressive about Samnee’s excellence is that he get’s there without doing anything outwardly flashy. It’s just page after page of awesome sequential art and lively characters. The influences of Alex Toth are readily apparent, but he is also mixing in a thick, softer line that is incredibly attractive. I also love that Samnee isn’t noodling with his art; sometimes the first few lines are the best and adding can sap the vitality of an image.
2. This is a Winter Soldier that I can enjoy. – For some reason, Winter Soldier never clicked with me. I know people gushed about how awesome he was when Brubaker first introduced him and I thought it was “okay”….but this is great stuff. Why is one clicking and the other isn’t? Well….I think Samnee probably deserves credit for that for delivering visuals that are burned into my brain. This issue shows a recently activated Winter Soldier. It’s hard to pin down the timeframe because of the slippery Marvel sense of time, but it has a very 1960’s vibe to it. Bucky has his brainwashing and is going about his business, but there are chinks in the mental armor that make his handlers nervous (like how he keeps reverting to speaking English).
3. Also a wonderful Black Widow. – Is Nastasha really in love with Bucky? Would she run away with him if his conditioning broke? Or is she just keeping a very close eye on Bucky for the Soviets? This Black Widow is wonderfully vague (and drawn very sexily by Samnee).
4. Rough moment with the kid. – You kinda need a moment in a comic story like this one to illustrate just how powerful the brainwashing of Bucky is. Showing him killing random Soviet dissidents just isn’t going to cut it because comic fans are so desensitized at this point. So, the creators give us a gut-wrenching scene of Bucky realizing that his target has his young daughter with him and he clearly doesn’t want to kill the dude in front of his kid. How Bucky handles it shows both his brainwashing and his humanity peeking through.
5. Great colors. – I think Samnee is probably among the easier artists to color because he’s already handled most of the shading and addition of depth. On the other hand, the linework is so great that if a colorist isn’t bringing their A-Game, they’re going to look pretty bad. Bettie Breitweiser’s colors do such a nice job of not fighting with what Samnee is doing. Some of her colors just flow naturally from the spot blacks that Samnee is laying down, but then she has the pages and panels where she is showing off by knowing how to mix these colors in such a tasteful way. When you look at her colors, they are really intricate and not flat at all, but she is still able to give the comic the feel and vibrancy of flat colors. For the millionth time I wish my coloring vocabulary was better so that I could do better justice to what she’s doing on the page.
Conclusion: This was a HOT comic from an artistic standpoint. The script isn’t awesome, but is perfectly fine. The main attraction is the art from Samnee and Breitweiser. Comics don’t get any more attractive that this.
Jumping on point?: It’s actually a pretty good spot to hop on. The last story cycle was all about Bucky and the Invaders, so this is the first issue of Bucky as Cold War Winter Solder. Hope on and revel in the art.
Grade: B+
-Dean Stell
Follow Dean on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion