By: Adisakdi Tantimedh (writer), Galen Showman & P. Craig Russell (artists), Dave McCaig (colorist)

The Story: I say, up in the sky!  It’s a bird, it’s a plane—oh, wait, those don’t exist yet.

The Review: I wasn’t sure how to classify these DC Comics Presents books.  Even though they’re released as “issues,” they really represent a collection of previously printed series, like a trade or graphic novel.  Function trumps form in my book, so graphic novels they will be.  Now that DC’s reaching out to a wider audience, it’s an ideal opportunity to showcase some of their great storylines of the past, and remind us why they’ve remained relevant for so many years.

The very concept of the Elseworlds imprint reveals how deeply rooted in the social conscious DC’s characters are.  Most people are well acquainted with their iconography and origins, and writers can use that familiarity to their advantage by crafting stories where we know from the start who the characters are and what motivates them.  This leaves our attention free to focus on the story’s premise and its underlying message.

To that, we must look first to the period, which spans the Second Industrial Revolution, one where America was at the very forefront.  It is significant that this technological era was the last to be characterized as a “revolution.”  While later decades yielded undoubtedly remarkable products, these largely built upon inventions inspired into being in the late 19th century.  Never before had progress advanced so quickly and with such enthusiastic acceptance and popularity.

Now imagine the introduction of superhumans to this equation.  In any circumstance, they’d have a destabilizing effect on the world, but here, in a clever twist by Tantimedh, Superman and his ilk seem more like sideshows to an age that had more than enough marvels to wonder at.  If anything, our heroes only accelerate these groundbreaking events, and even then, not by much.  Even though in this world the Germans launch the first atom bomb against another nation, they do so in 1911, less than forty years before us Americans did the same thing for real in WWII.

It is the difference in reasoning between the fictional and non-fictional culprits of atomic warfare that reveal the dark truth of this “Age of Wonder.”  In the story, the Germans release the bomb “in retaliation against the humiliation heaped upon [their] troops by the Green Lantern and British forces…”  The emphasis on “humiliation” tells you the principles are at stake during this time: the pride and supremacy of nations.  Any stain to those two elements represents an act of impudence that must be immediately quashed.

Ultimately, this petty mindset becomes the basis for almost all the advancements made in the story, and is embodied in the person of Lex Luthor.  This was a time when black-and-white ideologies promulgated freely.  Thus, you have Luthor’s complete lack of scruples (“Without money, there would be no society.”) butting heads with Clark’s surplus of it (“…but that shouldn’t stop us from using what we learn to benefit the world…”), and revealing the moral blind spots of both.

Here, in Real World, technology has gone even further than before, and the face of the Earth has changed dramatically, but the questions this story presents remain as relevant as ever.  Green Arrow gestures to the downtrodden working man and asks, “You stand for science and progress…who will stand for justice?”  This query is echoed later as Lois, in reaction to the devastation of war, stares wildly from her panel and seemingly asks us directly, “Is this what it’s all come to?  All those inventions, all that progress, all for us to finally destroy ourselves–?!”

Showman and Russell effect a simple style of linework that reflects the simpler age presented, and while it lacks the dynamism of modern action comics, it never looks stiff or unconvincing.  When the panels close in on the characters, the art grows deeper still, giving the faces great expression, charmingly exaggerated and sincerely dramatic by turns.  McCaig makes smart choices in colors, like having Superman stand out with eye-popping primary hues amidst a palette of more reserved grays, browns, greens, and even reds.

Conclusion: A straightforward, engagingly told tale with all the requisite winking Easter eggs, but also with plenty of thoughtful ideas to consider and reflect upon the age we live in.

Grade: A-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Incidentally, I appreciate the portrayal of Edison as an arrogant tyrant with a knack for employing the right people and taking credit for their ideas.  Though his enterprise and work ethic are justifiably admired, in real life he had, as one of his contemporaries put it, “a vacuum where his conscience ought to be.”

Grade

Conclusion