
By: Gregg Hurwitz (writer), Szymon Kudranski (artist), John Kalisz (colorist)
The Story: Penguin goes on a blind date.
The Review: Speaking as someone who was born with a negligible share of good looks, I can say with some experience that when you have a less than magazine-worthy appearance, you have to work a little harder. Attractive people start off with a good impression by default; the rest of us have to make an effort to earn even just that, not to mention the pains we must take to keep it.
That’s the struggle and frustration Penguin must live with, the price of his unappealing figure. For all the power he wields, for all his intoxicating wealth, for all the fear he can instill in those who cross him, he still can’t command the respect of others by his mere presence, unlike a certain cowled foe of his. His vow last issue to wipe the smile off every face in Gotham signals his intent to ensure no one ever laughs at him—even behind his back—again.
Whatever his plans to set that goal in motion, they got derailed by the untimely death of his mother, an event which haunts him throughout this issue. Just as he’s set to start his campaign to dominance, the loss of his emotional tether reduces him to a powerless fop who can only strike uselessly at his family mausoleum with his umbrella. Without that core of love, all the power he’s built around himself seems ready to collapse, revealing their superficial, fragile nature.
Love is really at the core of this series; it’s not a coincidence the most revealing scene lands right in the middle of the issue. There, Penguin has a second victim “brought” and makes him suffer equally to the first. Since you know how this particular tactic goes, it’d be a redundant scene had Hurwitz not wisely written a parallel opposing sequence of Oswald offering rich rewards the woman who nursed his late mother. In her refusal (“…love doesn’t require any payment at all”), she describes the old cliché and the void in his life: money can’t buy someone to love you.
Enter Cassandra, a blind woman quite nearly Oswald’s size, who immediately arrests his heart with her haplessly naivety. Tenderness ensues, of course (“Warmth is never lost. Because when it is given, it is also received.”). Now, I appreciate a good romance, but having seen more than a healthy share of Korean dramas, the storyline of an ugly man hooking up with a blind girl seems a bit too saccharine for my taste—not to mention predictable. We all know at some point the truth will come out, so his attempts to impress her in the meantime are a rather futile exercise.
On the other hand, Hurwitz crafts a love interest who seems rather too good to be true. Blind, gullible, and a sweetheart to boot? It may be cynical to think this way, but what exactly is her game here? Is she genuinely quirky and charming, or meticulously so for the sake of taking advantage of Oswald? Facts point toward the latter. She immediately identifies the ring he gives her as having nine karats. As cloying as her reply, “If I touch something, I can see it,” may be, it doesn’t explain how she knows about the differences in karats in the first place.
Hurwitz’s script depends on his impeccable timing to shine, and Kudranski pulls it off without fail. Each beat of each panel receives a complementary change of POV; the artwork heightens and accents every pregnant pause and every line of dialogue. Obviously, the best example of this is Penguin opening a door to reveal, once again, Joker in yet another kinky scene, leading to his nonplussed reaction: “Really?” Kalisz’s monochrome coloring adds a perpetually eerie tone to the series, and he fine-tunes it perfectly to prevent it from becoming monotonous.
Conclusion: For a Big Fat Middle issue, even one with a slightly overused plotline, this is a remarkably strong one, subtly weaving theme and plot together seamlessly to make an engrossing and entertaining read.
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – I hope Joker makes at least one more cameo before this mini runs out. They give the series that much-needed laugh. Love how his victim whimpers, “…help…me…” only for Penguin to complain, “Can we put some damned numbers on these doors?”
– Sorry, Cass, but mistaking a ferret hardly bigger than a man’s hand as a leg of a “big and strong” creature? That’s a pretty significant mix-up, is all I’m saying.
Grade
Conclusion