By: Simon Spurrier (writer), Paul Davidson (art), Rachelle Rosenberg (colors), Cory Petit (letters) & Daniel Ketchum (editor)

The Story: The X-Club helps to launch the world’s first space elevator. But all doesn’t go as planned.

Five Things: 

1. Dr. Nemesis is fun as hell. – I think there are a lot of comic writers who wish they could be Dr. Nemesis.  He’s smart, not physically imposing, has a huge vocabulary and a gift for turning a phrase.  You can just tell that the writers all seem to enjoy writing his dialog and that enthusiasm transfers to the reader.  Nemesis is the only reason the X-Club (the team…not the comic book) is remotely interesting.  Love when he tells the assembled press at the space elevator’s launching that he’s considering performing a “surprisingly painful procedure” on them called a “stupidectomy.”  Even when he’s not coining new words, it’s just fun to watch him ask the media, “Doesn’t anyone have an interesting question?”  The man doesn’t suffer fools!

2. Feels really contemporary in the current X-Men status-quo. – Personally, I think it’s vital for these lesser miniseries to feel very rooted in the current status quo because the only people who buy them are the hardcore who buy all/most of the X-books.  So, bravo to Spurrier for using small and humorous elements of the story to ensure that we know this is a post-Schism story.  He shows Cyclops continually correcting the speaker who calls them “The X-Men” by interjecting, “…. of Utopia!”  At one point they even show Wolverine watching the broadcast on TV and uttering a nasty word at Cyclops for continually making this correction.  Very funny and fresh…

3. LOTS of unanswered questions. – There are a few too many odd things going on in this issue.  We start with a flashback to the Invaders doing something in WWII and that “something” obviously ties into the Atlantean tribes upset at the space elevator and how one of them goes all monstrous.  And then something happens with Danger.  It’s just a bit too much tossed together in the opening issue and the linkages aren’t clear.  I like teasers as much as the next guy, but this was too much.  And is there a reason that the X-Men keep Danger around?  How many times has she gone nutso on them?

4. Solid art. – The art is very solid and the storytelling is effective.  There’s nothing flashy here that makes me weep with joy, but neither were there any really problematic sequences.  Davidson should absolutely be in the rotation of X-artists before they let guys like Greg Land and Steve Kurth handle a pencil again.  And, I’m very impressed with the coloring by Rachelle Rosenberg.  She’s improving rapidly as a colorist and I really enjoy this two-tone color that she is doing in this issue.

5. LOVE the Nick Bradshaw cover. – This guy is really talented.  I mean REALLY talented.  It reminds me of when I was a kid and all of a sudden this Arthur Adams dude showed up.  He also reminds me a bit of Terry Moore too with all the hyper-detailed fine lines.  Just look at the linework on that cover; the cross hatching, Nemesis’ jacket and tie flailing to show movement…  He’s even got this cool mechanical framing element.  My only hope is that Marvel doesn’t relegate him to doing covers.

Conclusion: This was fine.  It mostly floats on the strength of Dr. Nemesis’ dialog and some very solid art.  If “they” manage to tie up all the subplots nicely, this could be a high quality miniseries.

Grade: C+

-Dean Stell

Follow Dean on Twitter.

Follow WCBR on Twitter and Facebook.

Grade

Conclusion