
By: Jonathan Hickman (writer), Dustin Weaver (artist), Sonia Oback, Rachelle Rosenberg, Christina Strain (colorists)
The Story: Man, I am experience some major crazy déjà vu right now.
The Review: Ten months ago, when I did my first review for this series, I felt pretty gung-ho about the type of story Hickman had to tell, and was confident in the direction he planned to take it. But with each issue that came down the pike, my interest grew more listless as the plot seemed to have no motivation to wrap itself up. I’d hate to be confrontational, but does anyone else think it’s a tad ridiculous for a story arc to take over a year to finish?
The crazy part is we’re still not actually at the finish line just yet. This issue has Leonid et al traveling through time to confront Newton at the end of the world—three times. By which I mean the gang uses the Human Machine to arrive simultaneously in three completely different possibilities of the future: one where human civilization has given way to the natural kingdom, one where technological utopia has been reached, and one that is merely a barren wasteland.
An interesting sequence, but with a fatal flaw: besides the difference in settings, the chain of action remains almost completely the same and the dialogue is only nominally altered by Hickman’s usual dose of grandiose wordage (“The next step. The arc of ascendency. The feedback loop. Tomorrow’s tomorrow.”). Sure, it makes a clear point about the immutability of human nature, but that doesn’t make it more exciting to read.
Nor does any of it advance the story in any significant way. It almost feels like an exercise for how long Hickman can drag out an event before he moves on to the next. It was just two issues ago that Newton fled from his battle versus the motley S.H.I.E.L.D. gang, and here they simply pick up where they left off with no real enlightening exchange—which kind of makes it seem like they all traveled to the end of the world for a change in scenery.
We also get introduced to three men of the Eastern branch of S.H.I.E.L.D., whose purposes and origins are rather obscure. We know them only as “the Last Caliphate, the three brothers of Causality,” or, as Tesla refers to them, “the embodiment of branching time.” By now, you should be in the habit of not expecting much elucidation beyond this kind of vague terminology, which is good because you won’t get any. The brothers speak little and serve little obvious purpose to the story.
At the end of the day, for all the high scientific concepts Hickman introduces, for all the celebrated figures of history he weaves into his tale, for all the battle of philosophies, this is still just a story about people chasing a deranged person through time to prevent him from commandeering history, and we all know how that goes: it doesn’t work. It’s never worked—DC’s Crises and Flashpoint proved that—and it all goes back to the status quo in the end.
One thing I can’t criticize is Weaver’s obvious devotion to this series, which has been beautifully illustrated from start to finish. If you’re a Marvel nut, you’ll particularly appreciate the two-page sequence of the Human Machine falling through Marvel’s timeline, from its Silver Age beginnings in the Fantastic Four to its theoretical future with the Next Avengers.
Conclusion: At this point, you don’t really care if the world ends or not, as long as the story ends with it. To the Dropped List this title goes.
Grade: C
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – This marks the end of all the Marvel titles I have on my Review List. Anyone have any suggestions for titles you’d like reviewed and no one else is already covering on the site?
Grade
Conclusion