
By: Kevin Eastman & Tom Waltz (writers), Dan Duncan & Mateus Santolouco (artists), Ronda Pattison (colorist)
The Story: Sorry Turtles, no one delivers pizza on Christmas Eve.
The Review: Much like my experience with Static Shock, I knew the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles as a cartoon long before I read them in comics, and even longer before I discovered they actually started out in pulp. To this day, I still look back on the Turtles with a kind of fond wonder. When you consider the very premise behind them, it’s rather amazing they took off at all, much less the multimedia success they’ve become in the last couple decades.
Reading this Eastman-Waltz penned series, it seems like there’s also room for the Turtles to grow as characters beyond the gimmicks and syndication. Not having read prior issues, I can’t say if this one is a good example of the kind of thing you get on the series all the time, but it’s surprisingly cogent, intriguing stuff, with nary a catchphrase to be seen.
This issue dives into the origins of Master Splinter, which turns out more complicated and violent than I remember. For one thing, his story begins centuries before the Turtles ever came into existence, in feudal Japan. As you might imagine, this means his narration here in the present day required a spiritual reincarnation or supernatural circumstances of some kind, which alone moves the series into more sophisticated territory.
All the indicators point to a plain-and-simple reincarnation, however. It can’t be a coincidence Hamato Yoshi had four sons, each with a distinctive personality which parallels with one of the Turtles. Nor can it be a coincidence that his sons inherited his skill in martial artistry, and the Turtles seem to have an natural instinct for the fighting arts. Both Donatello and Raphael note their training feels more like “fine-tuning something we already learned,” so the connection to Yoshi’s sons seems pretty strong.
If so, that makes Splinter’s affectionate interaction with the Turtles all the more emotional. My memories aren’t perfect, but I don’t recall the spry rat being that obviously expressive toward his protégés. To see him encouraging his “sons” and telling them how much he cherishes them—well, call me sentimental, but it’s actually quite moving, especially given how gruesome and tragic Yoshi’s last moments with his sons in old Japan turned out to be.
We only catch a brief scene with April O’Neil (a college student in this iteration), who seems set to run into one Casey Jones, a guy who loves hockey but struggles with the books. It’s not clear what role either of them will play in the ongoing adventures of the Turtles, but the fact April’s offering tutoring in exchange for self-defense lessons and Casey finds “crackin’ dudes in their skulls” second nature probably means they’ll get a piece of the action in time.
Duncan has a squashy style of drawing characters, which works perfectly for a series featuring humanized animals (and vice versa). He gives their faces an almost Claymation flexibility, allowing them some supremely endearing expressions. Santoluoco’s attention to period wear and architecture makes the scenes in feudal Japan quite convincing, and the way he makes all the characters’ faces kind of pointy has a distinctly Japanese aesthetic. Pattison does her best to differentiate the Turtles by their skin color, but since I’m not color-nuanced, I still had a hard time telling them apart without their color-coded eye-masks.
Conclusion: It takes some craft and much love to make a bunch of oversized, mutant turtles who like pizza into credible protagonists, and that’s exactly what the creative team has done here. I’m happily onboard for now.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Can I just say how happy I am to see a hockey jock (besides The Office’s Michael Scott) in fiction for once? The whole world doesn’t play American football, folks!
– I dare anyone to look up the NYC area code and dial the number April put on her ad. Bonus points if you hit a sex and/or suicide hotline.
Grade
Conclusion