
By: Gregg Hurwitz (writer), Szymon Kudranski (artist), John Kalisz (colorist)
The Story: It’s only fair, Penguin, that you give Hitchcock credit for half your evil plan.
The Review: Like the vast majority of comic book villains, Penguin lacked much of the depth that made so many of his brethren standouts. He had a recognizable appearance, and a very clear theme, but strip all that away and character-wise, he really was nothing more than your common mafia boss with mercenary values. Notice, however, my use of the past tense.
Because right about now—and I can’t believe I’m writing this—Penguin has become one of the most intriguing villains on the new DCU. While he’s not nearly on par with Joker or Luthor, those paragons of criminals, Hurwitz has given him such complexity in this mini that he’s easily more compelling than most the other evil-doers running about in other comics.
While this story has produced some great dramatic sequences with Oswald Cobblepot, perhaps no other scene better defines his point of view than when he speaks directly into the three-way mirror during his interrogation. After pointing out the atrocities of his victims, he asks, “Am I any better? Of course not. But I’m not any worse. Do you ever question it? Why you protect them? And why you drag me in here…? Of course not… You know why? Because they look like one of you. And I…I look like one of me.”
I quote a lot of this monologue for several reasons. One: it has that perfect mixture of defiance and vulnerability that makes him contemptible, admirable, and sympathetic all at the same time. Two: it gives you some food for thought not only about the story at hand, but about our own grayish outlook on who’s a “bad” person and how we treat them in the real world.
Third, and perhaps most crucially, Penguin’s words have an actual effect on his enemies. It’s a credit to both Hurwitz and his star character that they manage to make you doubt the infallibility of both Gordon and Batman’s moral compass. And in fact, Batman himself calls their judgment into question. He reflects on his gut-presumption of one of Penguin’s victims as a “Good kid from a good family,” only to discover he sold ecstasy. It’s not clear where this introspection leads, but it’s a significant moment, nonetheless.
Ultimately, this kind of character work is what’ll count in the end, but Hurwitz tops it all off with a fairly action-packed plot, in contrast to the more sedate chain of events of past issues. Penguin begins to make good on his vow in #3 to make Gotham give him due respect, and honestly, his plan is both logistically challenging (Batman takes a major tumble to overcome the first attack), and poetic, drawing on motifs Hurwitz introduced throughout the mini.
All this material is so solidly integrated that in contrast, the beats featuring Penguin’s fiancée, Cassandra, feel a bit out of place. Still, she serves an important role in insisting that her new boyfriend isn’t just a cruel guy with a grudge against bullies. I may have been wrong to suspect her lack of scruples last time, but actually, that will only make her discovery of his daily activities all the more heartbreaking.
I should have seen this before, but this issue really calls attention to Kudranski’s remarkable ability to use shadow and darkness to his advantage. Overall, this is a very dimly lit issue, with Kalisz’s dark palette, but Kudranski tastefully draws your eye to specific parts of the image that are actually visible in almost impressionistic technique to create a consistent series of motifs, like Penguin’s monocle, beaky nose, and grimace—very smart, tasteful choices.
Conclusion: This series has been strong from day one and it looks set to finish on a high note. By this point, even if the last issue goes nowhere, there’s enough to make the story overall a really impressive take on a formerly unimpressive character.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – I find it brilliantly disturbing that Penguin launches his “missile” at schoolchildren with Cass, reading Braille, in the room, as if they’re just having a quiet couple’s diversion at home.
Grade
Conclusion