
By: Scott Snyder & Scott Tuft (writers), Attila Futaki (art), Greg Guilhaumond (colors) & Fonografiks (letters)
The Story: Don’t follow creepy old men into backwoods tool sheds!
3 Things:
1. The cat is out of the bag. – The creators have kept this game going for a few issues where the reader knew more about the bogeyman than young Jack did. Honestly, they managed this suspense about as well as I’ve seen in comics and gave us all these ‘No! Don’t follow the strange man into the _______!’ moments. But, the creators also knew when to stop the game and just let the story come to its climax. What I loved about the scene with the shed in the woods is that the set up wasn’t much different than all the other teases we’ve gotten AND this scene happened early in the comic, so I half-expected this to be yet another tease. However, the one difference in this scene is that Jack knew the bogeyman was a bad man so it really made sense to pop the balloon and move on with the story (even if I DO miss the masterful teasing from the last few issues).
2. Still a lot of little mysteries about the bogeyman. – Who is he? Where did he come from? Is he just a cannibal or is he some kind of meta-human? How did he know Jack’s father? Is he Jack’s father (in a Darth Vader/Anakin Skywalker sort of way)? Why all the fucking around? Why not just eat him when they first met? Is there more to the story with Sam? How did he get away from the bear trap? How in god’s green earth is Jack getting out of this mess only losing an arm? Would the Old Man Jack we saw in issue #1 be able to even walk by an old shed without wetting himself? I can’t wait to find out.
3. Great art. – I’m a huge fan of stylized art in my comics. I’ll take an artist like Chris Bachalo over someone trying to draw like Alex Ross any day of the week. The reason for that is that most realistic artists just aren’t good enough. When you try to draw realistic faces, clothes, bodies and buildings and you mess up anything, our eyes and brains call BS on the entire page of art because we know what those items should look like even if we can’t draw them ourselves. That being said, the art combo of Futaki and Giulhaumond could teach classes in realistic art. This looks great and they have the wonderful gift that when they DO deviate slightly from realism, it serves a story-telling purpose and we accept it as such. Maybe it’s just the difference between deviating intentionally and other artists just not being able to draw noses properly?? Anyway, this book looks great. And, MAJOR kudos need to go to colorist Guilhaumond. His work is what really puts the art over the top and sells that this Depression-era tale is dusty, sweaty, smelly, etc.
Conclusion: This is a great miniseries and I fully expect the creators to nail the landing next month. If you haven’t been reading the single issues and you like horror, the collected edition is a CAN’T MISS. Scott Snyder teased that they may turn this into an ongoing series. Not sure how they do that, but hope that it happens.
Grade: A-
-Dean Stell
Follow Dean on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion