
By: Peter J. Tomasi (writer), Claude St. Aubin (penciller), Scott Hanna (inker), Gabe Eltaeb (colorist)
The Story: There’s a reason why the benefits are so good when you join the Green Lanterns.
The Review: I don’t know about you, but I know that for me, living in our pampered, lily-handed world, the sweatiest decisions I’ve ever had to make involved no higher stakes than minor monetary loss or brief social discomfort—and if you can live out the rest of your days that way, consider yourself lucky. For those who go into professions where they actually hold people’s lives in their hands, the burden of being the one to call the shots is a heavy one, indeed.
That said, we all understood John did the best thing under the circumstances last issue when he put Kirrt down before the young Lantern screwed all of Oa (and thereby much of the universe) by giving way to the Keepers’ torture. Vandor, who witnessed the act, serves as our voice in the issue, supporting John in his decision, even going so far as to request that he hopes John would “give me the same honor you did Kirrt before allowing me to betray the Corps.” Note the use of the word “honor” to blunt the harsh truth of what John did. Note also that Vandor fails to realize that he has the luxury of giving John permission to do such a thing to him; Kirrt did not.
In any case, Vandor obviously feels there’s no reason for John to feel shame for what he did, and he says so. John, of course, doesn’t quite see it that way, but for all his manifestations of guilt and angst, you also have to consider how he doesn’t report what really went down to anyone—not even Guy, to whom he flat-out lies so as to make Kirrt’s death not the tragic result of betrayal it was, but rather an act of heroism. Such deception must stand revealed, sooner or later, so John’s cover-up seems rather imprudent and fruitless.
On the other hand, he has good reason for feeding those white lies to Kirrt’s family. This is the kind of thing Tomasi does so well: even though we’re dealing with completely alien creatures and fantastic circumstances here, the emotions are entirely recognizable to us. It doesn’t get more heartrending than the son who goes off to battle in honor, only to return in sorrow. Yet despite the obvious pathos of the sequence, I’m not sure Tomasi does anything out-of-the-ordinary with it, besides the even more pathetic exchanges with Birrt, Kirrt’s younger bro.
Tomasi has also been aces at developing the culture and substance of the Green Lantern mythos, like the ceremony honoring Kirrt’s (fabricated) sacrifice. In that scene, you get a great sense of the Corps’ nobility and ancientness, aspects Geoff Johns only hints at in his more epic plots. You also have to love how Tomasi creates this feeling of a shared universe in this series; the different reactions of various species watching John fly by with Kirrt’s coffin is not only poignant, but rich in its imagination as well.
I had little love for St. Aubin’s work on R.E.B.E.L.S., and even with Hanna’s excellent inkwork and Eltaeb’s lush colors dressing up the pencils and making them look more profound than they really are, I have to say I’m glad St. Aubin is only doing a guest job on this issue. Especially in comparison to regular artist Fernando Pasarin’s beautiful work, St. Aubin’s clunkly lines have little expression, depth, and reality. This is most painfully clear when it comes to his sets, which are basically series of polyhedrons that have no culture, design, or personality to them.
Conclusion: A sympathetic treatment of what happens after the dust clears and you find yourself having to keep your conscience secret from others. Unfortunately, weak art defeats the emotional wallop this issue otherwise holds.
Grade: B-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Apparently, Lockheed’s brethren exist in the DCU as well—check out three of them flying around and perched on Cryptkeeper Morro’s shoulders.
Grade
Conclusion