By: Jeff Parker (writer), Kev Walker (penciller), Terry Pallot (inker), Frank Martin Jr. (colorist)

The Story: It’s safe to say in this situation, Songbird, you let him get into your head.

The Review: I hate to admit it, but my tendency to read and favor DC comics often keeps me in the dark when it comes to my familiarity with Marvel continuity.  In a world with Wikipedia, however, that’s not really much of an obstacle.  Still, there are moments when lack of knowledge about the more obscure parts of a character’s backstory can undercut a story’s impact, especially if the writer is using those parts as a springboard for whatever plot he’s weaving at the moment.

For example, I have pretty much zero experience with Songbird, and what I’ve seen of her since I jumped aboard this series has only done so much to fill me in on the villainess-turned-heroine’s background.  And so I’m afraid the significance of what Doctor Dorcas does to her here was quite lost on me until one quick Wiki-check later.  Even with that in mind, this issue doesn’t really do much except give our featured protagonist a boost to her already considerable powers.

The problem is Parker doesn’t spend as much time diving into Songbird’s state of mind as he needs to for us to make the emotional connection between where she starts the issue and where she ends up.  In fact, we never really get beyond a vague impression that she’s a bit tired from the stresses of a Thunderbolt life—which is hardly unusual.  You can sense her weariness goes deeper than that, but Parker doesn’t enlighten you whether her comments about living a “real life” just drinking, finding shells, and isle-hopping all day is sincere or daydreaming.

For that reason, you can’t help feeling like Songbird must not have ever been meant for a life of villainy as she falls for the “mysterious, handsome stranger who turns out to be a barechested, backstabbing tool” trick a little too easily.  Really, Kei (“Dorcas got my loyalty the old fashioned way.  He paid for it.”) doesn’t really have to do much more than send her a free drink, take off his shirt, and invite her on his speedboat before she falls into his arms, so that’s not the greatest reflection on her perceptiveness.

You can only hope this rather awful incident doesn’t traumatize her too badly.  You especially hope this doesn’t start off a long-term plotline where Songbird begins to reconsider her moral allegiance, or strays back towards the dark side.  Truly reformed villains are few and far in-between, so you just hope, as a matter of principled conviction, that they’ll be rewarded for turning their backs on crime.

At least we get a pretty dramatic re-introduction to Doctor Dorcas.  For an old Namor villain, he comes across very sinister, probably because anyone who can be so invasive in his malevolence (Dorcas is a surgeon—a brilliant and careful one, by all the evidence) gets an instant jump in his threat factor.  Besides, it’s always interesting to meet a criminal whose interest in the hero is more obsessive than avenging (“I have every news recording of you in action, when you used to use your beautiful voice.”).

Walker (whom I believe I referred to as “Wacker” in #169—my apologies) still has this strange effect where his art seems to vacillate between appearing delicate and sketchy, then looking bold and luscious—which works, actually.  With Pallot’s inks and Martin’s colors, Walker manages to convey realism in his figures without undermining their liveliness.  Songbird’s fear and anxiety in Dorcas’ operating room has loads of genuine tension to it, and yet her expression at getting a free drink has a cartoony confusion that makes it even funnier than written.

Conclusion: Another solid read with equally solid art, though it doesn’t do much to further flesh out one of Thunderbolts’ principal characters as it should.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – In just a few pages, Doctor Dorcas makes himself a prime competitor for Comic Lech of the year.  In volunteering to accompany Songbird’s singing, he claims,  “I’m a bit of an old hand with an organ.”  Gross.

Grade

Conclusion