By: Michael Green & Mike Johnson (writers), Mahmud Asrar (artist), Dave McCaig (colorist)

The Story: Supergirl’s first trip to the Big Apple, and it’s under crisis.  Perfect timing, right?

The Review: Look, I love big, drawn-out action scenes as much as the next guy.  That opening chase sequence in the newest Casino Royale is a sequence of beauty that I still haven’t gotten tired of.  But there’s a big difference between watching and relishing each punch, kick, flip, dash, jump, shot, blast, and explosion in, say, a ten-minute piece of big-screen cinema, and seeing a truncated, stationary version of the same thing across however many pages of comics.

Admittedly, it also makes reviewing a little harder.  I mean, how much can you really say about an issue that’s just one big punchfest, as this one is?  You can comment on the creative uses of superpowers, I suppose.  Supergirl does employ a few neat tricks in her battle against four Worldkillers, like releasing her internal energy through her skin in an outward blast.  That’s another skill set we’ve never seen her cousin employ, so we should see how that evolves later.

Sometimes it’s not just the raw power that makes for entertaining reading, but the special tactics employed on the fly.  When Reign conveniently mentions that “Only a Worldkiller can defeat another Worldkiller,” Supergirl makes the quick, sensible inference from that statement and forces one of them to strike down the other.  More significantly, she does so in rather brutal fashion; had Reign been less concerned for her comrades, one of them would certainly have died from Supergirl’s attack.  This unhesitating use of extreme violence will be something else we can look to cause drama later, especially once Superman gets involved with her life.

If you’re lucky, the writer will liberally sprinkle in some interesting, albeit awkward, exposition throughout the fight sequence.  Green-Johnson do this, but aside from some foreboding warnings about a missing, fifth Worldkiller, much of what Reign has to say are just reruns of what she’s made plain already: the Worldkillers as illicit Kryptonian experiments; their planet-devastating deadliness; their lack of information regarding the particulars of their origins; and the fact that only Kara stands to match them in strength and power.  It’s all quite repetitive and tiresome, bogging down the bulk of the issue.

Probably the most crucial bits of information we get out of this issue comes from the subtext of things.  Kara hasn’t really exerted much personality thus far in the series.  Like Barry Allen in The Flash, she’s been more reactive than proactive, and given her guarded, cerebral approach to things, she doesn’t quite let you into her inner self as easily as other characters do.  Still, here we get some valuable insight as to her determination (Reign: “Why continue a fight you cannot win?”  Kara, as she drops a police car on her: “…I’m stubborn.”) and compassion (“Krypton might be gone…but there’s still something left to save.”).  The people she’s protecting can’t fail to see that and make the connection with the “S” she wears on her chest.

Asrar does some solid action scenes—thank God, as that’s all we have here—as his lines are loose enough to convey a raw, youthful energy, but tight enough to put in credible detail where needed.  When Supergirl drops that police car, you can see all the individual pieces of glass smash off the headlights, the various pieces of equipment flying out the trunk, and every dent, crack, and twisted piece of metal on the frame.  Believe it or not, that kind of thing makes a big difference in the credibility of the art.

Conclusion: A rather bland way to finish up this new Supergirl’s second arc, but at least it leaves her free to pursue whatever future she wishes from here on out.

Grade: C+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Considering they’re facing down an alien creature that just tore off the spire atop the Chrysler Building and used it as a bat, it takes some serious guts from the NY cops to face her down with just a pistol.

– Hold on a sec—“Deimax” (the ripped sabretooth Worldkiller with an emo haircut) is a girl?  Wow.  I guess that’s all I have to say to that.

Grade

Conclusion