
By: Too many to list—check out the review.
The Story: Apparently, even a simple question of “dead or alive” has no straight answers.
The Review: Of course, the thing about having a huge relaunch of your entire line of titles is you’re not only thinning out all the weaker series, but the strong ones as well. While DC made certain to preserve its anchors (e.g. Batman, Green Lantern) more or less intact, its young critical darlings did not receive such protection, sending perfectly strong titles to an early end. I would definitely list T.H.U.N.D.E.R. Agents (as well as the underappreciated Xombi) as example.
This miniseries is thus something of a weird beast. You’d think DC going through the trouble of releasing it in the first place would be an indication of their faith in the property, especially since they have no shortage of more popular ones to invest in. Yet from the first issue, it’s clear the series doesn’t make itself out to be accessible or attractive to new readers. Rather, this mini feels mostly like a continuation of the spare plotlines Nick Spencer left behind on his ongoing.
At the same time, Spencer’s plotlines aren’t of the kind that resolve neatly or quickly; if you’ve ever read Morning Glories or any of his other works, you’ll know his strength lies in letting his stories ferment, giving you the occasional potent taste, but otherwise reserving the rest. For that reason, I find it hard to believe he ever intended for us to discover Colleen’s true loyalties this soon, or what her (and Emil Jennings’) ultimate goals are.
For the same reasons, Spencer’s attempts to tie in those revelations to this current conflict with the Subterraneans feel clumsy and unfounded. Sure, he’s done a fine job making the plight of these underground people credible and sympathetic, but to say that Jennings and Colleen have been working in secret together for Lord knows how long just to allow the Subs their “Spring” is too much a stretch. Worse still, all this gets revealed to us through an onslaught of exposition, making it even clearer that Spencer had a much lengthier execution period in mind.
But the most damning evidence of all in regards to this rushed wrap-up of what’s meant to be a longer-running storyline is the completely inadequate use of the title characters. Aside from Colleen, none of the Agents have been fleshed out as thoroughly as you’d wish for a series on the verge of ending. Even with NoMan and Toby you feel you’ve only scratched the surface of their potential, while Lightning and Dynamo are basically untouched.
If anything, the art only highlights the disappointed expectations of this series. Wes Craig’s slight, cartoony figures haven’t done much to bring Spencer’s dramatic script to life, even with the help of Hi-Fi’s vibrant colors. Mike Choi’s brief guest sequence doesn’t do much to lift the visuals either, consisting solely of talking heads, and filled in with harsh, rough colors that feel too vivid for the somber tone of the scene.
As for the “Undersea Agent” back-up, well—it’s baffling, to say the least. Why, when it seems the Agents’ adventures have nearly come to end, do we have this “secret origin” type tale about a character who doesn’t feature in any other part of the series? Michael Uslan writes it well enough, and Trevor McCarthy’s loose, kinetic lines look great drawing it, but no matter how you look at it, it’s a pointless bit of story that has no relevance whatsoever.
Conclusion: However you might have imagined this series to end up, this definitely isn’t it. The story indifferently strolls towards its conclusion, deprived of its usual sparkle and enthusiasm.
Grade: C+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – I must say, in terms of ironically understated final words, “Makes me want to puke” definitely lands in the top ten.
Grade
Conclusion