By: Kevin Eastman & Tom Waltz (writers), Dan Duncan (artist), Ronda Pattison (colorist)

The Story: It’s generally not a good idea to take your girlfriend down a sewer on the first date.

The Review: The hot news this week is Michael Bay, director of the next Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles film adaptation, plans to revitalize the franchise by removing the “Teenage” and “Mutant” parts entirely and making them aliens instead.  In my determined pursuit of objective review, I’ll wait to see how the movie pans out before getting rendering judgment, but even I can’t help feeling like Bay will have a lot of work before him to make this idea work.

I understand the point of these changes is to remove some of the hokier elements from the Turtles’ conception and make them more believable.  But let’s say we revise Superman’s origins so he’s an Earth-born genetic anomaly rather than the last child of a doomed planet who happens to be sent to our planet.  Sure, it’d be more sensible and less corny, but I doubt many people would see it’s an improved story.

The stakes may be lower here, but the changes are no less significant for the Turtles.  The loss of their “teenage” status would remove a major part of their endearing and enduring appeal.  True, their jocky mentality and mannerisms can get gimmicky and a tad annoying, but that’s what make these freaks lovable rather than terrifying.  I mean, how can you be scared of giant turtle-men armed with traditional Eastern weaponry who call you “Bro” and compliment you on the “Cute girl” you have passed out in your arms?

That unconscious girl, by the way, is April O’Neil, brought by Casey Jones to the sewers to meet his turtle buddies, who also happen to be the ninjas she claims nearly killed her some time back.  The intersection between the human and reptile characters of the series means our core cast is finally complete, though it may be a while—especially on April’s part—before they all fight as common allies.  Looking forward to much entertaining exchanges among them to come.

On a similar note, I must express my hope that Bay doesn’t remove the brotherhood/family aspect of the team, which is yet another of their endearing traits.  First of all, family plays a smaller role in comics relationships than lovers, friends, and comrades, so the Turtles are special in that regard.  Second, there’s something really weird and funny, yet kind of delightful, about a band of oversized turtles who call a robed rat with a walking stick their father.

And if Bay does decide to remove the “mutant” parts of the Turtles’ characters, then he’s removing not only one of the major elements of their mythos, but also one of the themes that underlies much of their stories and conflicts.  Half their enemies and acquaintances are mutants of some kind, like the eye-patched Hob or the breast-bound wolf (fox?) ninja (whom Stockman calls Krang’s “competitor”).  Krang’s whole plan for world domination revolves around creating a mutant army based on Stockman’s research on genetics.  Take away the “mutant” in TMNT, and suddenly the whole of their continuity feels less cohesive and powerful.

Turning back to the world of comics, Duncan does great work.  He has the right look for a “youth” title—these are teenaged turtles, after all—since his lines are loose and kinetic enough to inject fun and humor into the title, but he has enough sophistication to make the more serious scenes work (the Turtles’ anger over Splinter’s kidnapping, for example).  Pattison enlivens the action with timely uses of bright, bold colors, but also scales back the intensity of her hues during quieter scenes, keeping you focused on the import of the words.

Conclusion: Somehow, the creative team of this series has managed to make the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles a viable if unconventional superhero team worthy of as much attention as teams from the Big Two.  Great entertainment, from start to finish.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – April’s paranoia apparently doesn’t extend to unfamiliar guys with martial arts skills inviting her, alone, to come with him into the sewer.

Grade

Conclusion