![]()
By: Paul Cornell (writer), Ryan Kelly (artist), Giulia Brusco (colorist)
The Story: They’re everywhere! In the mirror! This couch! That potted plant over there!
The Review: It’s been a long time since I thought about the show, but it seems appropriate to mention The X-Files here. Fear of what’s out there has been a recurring theme in fiction since The War of the Worlds, but X-Files capitalized on that sentiment, combined it with growing distrust of the government, added in a heaping helping of psychological thriller, and became the exemplar of its genre. Every similar work since feels redundant and familiar as a result.
You can’t tell at this point how far Cornell can break away from the trends and themes X-Files established, but one thing’s for sure: his gift for dialogue and character work will always ensure whatever he writes feels fresh and different. The heated exchange between Chloe and Arcadia (and, to a lesser degree, Harry) in the limo embodies much of what makes Cornell an effective writer. The way Arcadia keeps Chloe firmly in line, almost commanding her to stay despite an admittedly tenuous story about visiting aliens (“You say it was ‘like a dream’? I think, therefore, that it was probably a dream!”), makes the would-be president that much more convincing, and that makes the premise in general that much more convincing.
Upon closer reading, you realize there’s so much groundwork getting laid down in this scene. Just because Arcadia perceives an impending alien invasion doesn’t mean she’s about to let that jeopardize her chances of appearing as a viable candidate for the White House. Yet at the same time that she demonstrates her governmental competence hasn’t diminished for her paranormal experiences, she also creates a sticky issue of political ethics: should someone whom we’re supposed to trust to lead the country be keeping a secret (delusional or no) this big from us?
And while the last-minute deal with Chloe manages to ensure the edgy adviser’s presence for now, you can’t really expect the hope of a “best-selling tell-all political memoir of all time” to substitute for loyalty. Chloe may be humoring Arcadia’s beliefs, but she makes her deep-rooted skepticism clear all the time: “Serious question: do you believe in UFOs? Okay, how to rephrase that in order to get a—comprehensible answer? Do…you…believe…in…UFOs?” Should the aliens prove real, Chloe may not be long for this team, no matter how tantalizing a book offer.
Even more uncertain is how far Harry’s loyalty to Arcadia goes. He serves as your old-school everyman—dedicated, compassionate, intelligent, and with just a hint of resignation to trouble. In some ways, he wants to clamp down on Arcadia’s alien talk more passionately than Chloe, though he professes his fealty at every turn. As interesting as his future with Arcadia will be, right now it’d be great to uncover how he became so entrenched in her work, life, and fate.
I haven’t even gotten to the mystery of Kidd’s prophetic Pioneer couple, Michael’s own troubles dealing with his alien encounter (and “private” issues), or the introduction of the creepily sensitive Dr. Glass, regressive hypno-therapist. But let’s move on to the art, regardless. Kelly’s work has definitely tightened up some, and looks more expressive and nuanced for it. He still has a knack for making the familiar (e.g. UFOs as white streaks in the sky) regain their original eeriness, and his varied use of perspective and distance keeps the largely talky series from feeling too stagnant and centered.
Conclusion: You may not come out of this a believer, but Cornell will grip you nonetheless in this tale of extraterrestrial paranoia. Well worth sticking around for the character dynamics, if nothing else.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Considering the Pioneer couple prove inexplicably accurate in all their predictions regarding Kidd, how should we take their reference to Arcadia as “your next president?”
– I’m no scientist, but I’m assuming Harry’s “above background norm” reading on the Geiger counter “[j]ust here. Just where the car was,” is important somehow, yes?
A Second Opinion
Recap/Review: Even though this comic is asking a lot of interesting questions and has introduced a lot of complex characters over just two issues, it is moving at a deliberate pace that keeps it from being quite as riveting as it could be. Of course, the slower pacing is probably why we have so many interesting characters after only 40 pages of comic. Let’s at least give Cornell and Kelly big credit for capitalizing on the slower pacing; a lot of creators just go slowly for no reason and to no advantage.
The central premise of this series seems to be: What if aliens really were invading? Would anyone take the believers seriously until it was too late? So, it’s interesting to see our central character take the approach that she needs to get elected President if she wants to do anything about it. If she talks about it on the campaign trail, she’ll be perceived as a loon by the general public and quickly be related to loserville. But…if she keeps silent, gets elected, learns the governments secrets and THEN acts…..well…..then she might be able to do something.
However, it’s going to be a problem when even those closest to her have a hard time believing her story. Her spunky (and awfully young) campaign manager doesn’t have a lot of patience, but is willing to ride it out as long as it isn’t a public issue. Her old-timer consiglieri is willing to play along too, but only in a fatherly sort of way. You can see him looking at our protagonist (Sorry….I don’t know these characters’ names yet) like a dad who knows his daughter is spinning a big, fat lie to cover up some shame.. He probably suspects that this whole aliens thing is related to being abused and possibly raped by her estranged husband.
Heck…even her doctor has questions when examining her: “Have you recently had anal intercourse, madam Governor?” Is there a correct way for a political candidate to answer that question. “I was raped.” or “I was anally probed by aliens.” both have their political problems. But, so would saying, “Why yes I did have anal sex! And I loved it.” Our protagonist is in a very delicate position because everything she says and does is going to get warped by our nutty political process. It’s a sad statement on our electorate, but a woman probably couldn’t get elected President if the National Enquirer is running a story suggesting that a female political likes to have anal sex. A male candidate could probably weather that news; women….not so much. So, you have to feel sorry for her. She’s walking a tightrope.
And then there’s all the detritus left in our abductee’s brains. She and her estranged husband are legitimately freaked out as human beings. They’re scared! You see this when she asks her protective detail to take off their sunglasses because they remind her of the aliens’ eyes or when her husband starts seeing alien faces during hypnosis. As adults, we don’t get to experience legitimate fear very often, but this comic reminds us of being a kid who was afraid of things that go bump in the night.
The final little winkle to this story is the scientist who looks to be the candidate’s science advisor. It’s wonderful how he keeps interacting with the “Pioneer Couple” (the naked man/woman on the Pioneer spacecraft). Last issue it seemed like these people were just a manifestation of his subconscious, but now it seems like there is more to it. These little folks know the future and they know things about the aliens. Are they the aliens?
The art is honestly a bit of a mixed bag for me. I’m a huge Ryan Kelly fan, but I’ve always seen him in black and white. In this comic, it looks like he’s dialing himself back a little bit to allow space for the colorist. The book is quite well colored, but this colored Ryan Kelly work still doesn’t quite compare to the SICK work he’s done in the past when he was working in B&W. Personally, I’d rather see this in his traditional B&W even if this is pretty good. These characters don’t have quite the glimmer of life that Kelly has given folks in series like NY5 (or perhaps the colorist is sapping that life?). Kelly excels at showing sadness and pain on a character’s face and we’ve got a LOT of sadness and pain in this comic….so, it’s a good fit. His women always seem to have this inner strength somehow. The guy also isn’t afraid of adding extra little details to scenes. Check out a panel or two….you’ll see all sorts of background details that are “extra” but add richness to the scene.
A final note: I really wish Vertigo would print this comic on that newsprint they use for I Vampire and a few other titles. This cheap, reflective stock isn’t getting it done. The quality of paper in comics is just atrocious right now. This is going to push me fully over to digital because the art looks better.
Conclusion: There are a ton of positives in this issue as Cornell and Kelly continue to do some strong character and story development. However, it isn’t a story that grabs you by the throat and demands that you pay attention. It’s lacking a little sense of “I can’t wait to see what happens next!” Still, it’s high quality and isn’t remotely at risk of being dumped from the pull list.
Grade: B+
– Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion