By: Brian Azzarello (writer), Cliff Chiang (artist), Matthew Wilson (colorist)

The Story: Don’t take this the wrong way, Diana, but death really becomes you.

The Review: My favorite creative writing professor in college loved Ernest Hemingway, and he got us to love him, too.  Even though Hemingway was a morose, chauvinist drunk who treated nearly all four of his wives unconscionably (third wife Martha was forced to take a ship full of explosives to meet him in London because he refused to help her get a press pass on a plane), his ability to craft stories of great depth from few words made him a master of the highest order.

Azzarello may be the Hemingway of comics today.  Whereas most of his contemporaries love to embellish their scripts, filling up panels with long captions of text, Azzarello goes for sparse bursts of dialogue which, like Hemingway’s famous “iceberg” analogy, contain profound levels of meaning beneath the surface.  He doesn’t impose his own interpretation of the story on you; he leaves you space to fill in with your own understanding and perspective.

While in the underworld, Diana is aghast to find the souls of the dead are indeed all around her—making the composition of hell itself.  Hermes claims that since mortal souls can thus reinvent themselves eternally, they have greater freedom than the gods, who must remain bound to their natures for their immortal lives.  Diana doubts any soul would wish to be “reinvented” into such horrors.  In response, Hermes says, “…Free will is a funny thing.”  The ambiguity of the statement leaves you free to interpret it as you wish.  Perhaps it’s noting how we’d prefer to endure pain rather than stagnancy; maybe it’s a commentary on how free will allows us to choose evil; it could also be Hermes’ way of saying we humans waste our freedoms.

At times, Azzarello’s minimalist scripting can be a double-edged sword.  It gives each word a semblance of import, but also produces ambiguity.  Hades says to Hermes, “You came here with one, but to get another.  So…which child of Zeus is your ‘we’?”  It’s a rhetorical, if confusing question, but for some reason it makes Hermes fly into an uncharacteristic rage.  Even now, after several readings, I confess I don’t know why Hades’ words provoke such a reaction.

The issue of vagueness comes up again when considering the overall direction of this story.  While Azzarello’s re-imagining of Greek mythology and his breakdown of our heroine has been rich and interesting, he has struggled to balance the two major threads of his plot: Zola’s pregnancy and the divine power-plays in Zeus’ absence, which itself is a lingering mystery.  We really haven’t gotten many answers on either thread after eight issues, and Wonder Woman coming up with plans on the fly that peter out to nowhere doesn’t help.

I have always maintained that nothing shows DC’s investment in this title than assigning Chiang as regular artist.  His ability to make the title character the epitome of both strength and beauty, without overplaying either aspect, is what makes him such an ideal fit for her.  His design of the “commando” wear for her trip to the underworld makes her look threatening, but also calls attention to her nobility and womanhood.  Any mainstream artist who can get the praise of Project Rooftop—the fashion gurus of comics—must be doing something right.  Also, it has to be said: the heart motifs within the gunfire from Eros’ guns is pretty darn cute.

Conclusion: Like Hermes, Azzarello guides you to your fated destination, though you’re left bewildered as to where.  Still, he and Chiang keep you enthralled along the ride.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Another reviewer characterized Wonder Woman semi-literally shooting herself in the foot (or chest, to be more precise) as “stupid.”  I disagree.  Since her gauntlets were also presumably forged by Hephaestus, it was natural for her to assume they’d defend against other godly weapons.

– Also, if we go by tradition, shouldn’t Diana fall in love not with the person who shot her, but the person she sees first, which, in this case, would be Zola?

Grade

Conclusion