hh
By: Peter J. Tomasi (writer), Fernando Pasarin (penciller), Scott Hanna (inker), Gabe Eltaeb (colorist)
The Story: This promotion better come with some cosmic benefits—health and dental!
Thgge Review: Guy Gardner reminds me a lot of a certain type of dude I used to know back as an undergrad: loud, strident, and not afraid to voice half-formed opinions and act on impulse. They were some of the most irritating human beings I have ever known in real life, but they were also some of the most big-hearted as well. You could always count on them to injure themselves to help you out—mostly because the risk of injury never occurred to them in the first place
Perhaps that’s the nature of Guy’s appeal. Even when he flies off the handle and does something crazy, he always has your back, and since he lacks any skill with tact, you can always rely on him to be straight with you. As a consequence, he reveals underneath all that noise and erratic behavior, there’s a very strict code of honor he adheres to. For anyone else, refusing to let the Yellow Lantern battery to even be buried standing would be a pointless act of symbolism; Guy’s violence and conviction make it clear even his most symbolic acts make a worthy point.
So perhaps it should come as no surprise that the Guardians choose to honor him as they do in this issue. They certainly make the accurate observation that for all of Guy’s spitting in the face of authority, he never threatened the “emotional and physical fabric of the corps” the way Hal Jordan does on a constant basis. The evidence speaks for itself within the scene; Guy may not think much of the Guardians’ discipline (“—here are my wrists—slap away.”), but far from undermining it, he voluntarily submits to it.
Even so, we have far too much experience to believe the Guardians don’t have some ulterior, darker motive to their decision. It’s clear they wouldn’t have given Guy a position of such prominence if they weren’t certain he “would answer only to us,” something you could never imagine Hal doing. It’s also clear they have no problem mollifying him through his ego and his desire to supplant Hal as primo Green Lantern (see the vision of him punching out Hal).
It’s a bit of a twist that the Guardians promote the frenetic Guy over his more placid, soldierly co-honor guardsman in John, but I don’t think this will drive the wedge between the two. Nor do I predict that Guy’s new responsibilities will somehow force him to judge John’s actions with more scrutiny than before. It’s the simple fact that Guy obviously trusts John implicitly and John won’t reveal a fairly damning secret to him; should make for some heated conflict in the future.
Something seems a bit off about the art this issue. I was bothered enough to dive into my box of back issues and pull out #1, which I have before me right now. Even though the creative team is exactly the same on both, the art here lacks the depth and gloss that made the book look so stunning in its debut. Flesh seems less defined and textured than before, and the overall detail looks less distinguished. I can’t tell you what would make such a difference, but it’s there, though the art is still remarkable enough, regardless.
Conclusion: A (relatively) quiet issue which recovers from the blistering action of the first story arc, only to set up the dramatic foundations for the next. The art also seems to be taking a break from its previously stellar quality in favor of something more average.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Of all the new rhyming oaths that have come out of Green Lantern in the last few years, the Alpha Lanterns’ may be my least favorite. It’s clumsy, cheesy, and it highlights how the Alphas aren’t really part of the main corps anymore.
– I’m actually shocked barfights don’t take place more often at Warriors.
– Also, when was the last time the policing agency within the police didn’t turn out to be even more corrupt than their supposed targets at the end?
Grade
Conclusion