
By: Michael Green & Mike Johnson (story), George Pérez (art), Bob Wiacek (inks), Paul Mounts (colors)
The Story: Unnecessary bangles, beanie hats—you’re really on Earth now, Supergirl.
The Review: No matter how much anyone emphasizes the Super-family’s non-human origins or background, the fact remains that they are heroes of Earth, not of Krypton, Kandor, Argos, Cadmus, or what-have-you. Supergirl pretty much proved that last issue when she defended New York City against invaders who came from her home planet. Over half a year later, the time seems right for her to make an emotional connection to this world she’s chosen as home.
Green-Johnson have done an admirable job of not letting our heroine get lost in her cousin’s big shadow, especially so early on in her career, so I appreciate that Kara doesn’t immediately turn to Clark for help now that she’s settled here. Instead, the writers throw in Siobhan Smythe, who serves as the ideal foil to Supergirl. Since she’s a fellow orphan and emigrant to America, she can sympathize with Kara in important ways, and her good-natured approach to the world will be particularly useful for acclimating her Kryptonian friend to human society.
Even though Siobhan’s super-linguistic powers seem like a blatant narrative necessity, purely a means so Kara can actually communicate with somebody, at least it makes some sense within Siobhan’s alter-ego as Silver Banshee. Speaking of which, Banshee has always been portrayed as a major Supergirl nemesis, so the idea of her civilian guise being friends with Kara makes you wonder how their relationship will evolve in time. Personally, I’d prefer an old-school, Green Lantern and Star Sapphire dynamic: friends out of costume, and enemies otherwise.
Although Kara has a potential bestie to hang around with and learn from, Green-Johnson make it clear that the adjustment period will go on for a while. In her last incarnation, I always found it unrealistic (for lack of a better term) how quickly Kara caught on to human language, customs, and technology. Here we see her surprise that television screens don’t magnify images by command and her annoyance of clothes that “could never learn to fit” her. These are minor issues compared to the unspoken questions as to what kind of life she should live now, since her advanced Science Guild intellect makes her overqualified for every job on Earth.
I think it’s also important for Green-Johnson to develop Kara’s personality beyond her reiterated “stubborn” quality. Most of her actions and thought processes in these first eight issues have been reactions to the dramatic events around her, but they don’t quite give us insight into her inner woman. We’ve only gotten hints of her natural warmth (her affectionate handling of baby Kal-El in #2, for example), but we have no idea if she’s actually warm—or funny, or sober, or sensible, outgoing, cynical, or optimistic. This should be the main focus of the next few issues.
I’ve implied this before, but I might as well come right out and say it: Pérez’s work just seems a bit out-of-touch with modern comics. Maybe it’s because his work is so recognizably associated to the Crisis on Infinite Earths era, but his art tends to call attention to its “comic” attributes. There’s a soapishness to the characters’ expressions, and an artificial, almost plastic quality to his figures that distracts me from being fully immersed into the story.
Conclusion: The title hasn’t regained the momentum it had in the early issues, and the character work doesn’t go as far as it should to make up for it, but the title still remains a credible portrayal of its star character.
Grade: B-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – I’m always curious as to how much research writers do when approaching dialect work in their dialogue. I’m no linguistics expert, but I always get the feeling that a lot of stereotypes go into this kind of thing.
Grade
Conclusion