
By: Scott Snyder (story), Yanick Paquette & Marco Rudy (art), Nathan Fairbairn & Val Staples (colors)
The Story: Abby hasn’t learned that it’s rarely a good idea to trust canned food of any kind.
The Review: One thing that’s become obvious about Snyder’s writing is he loves to take his time. I don’t mean his pacing is slow; I mean that every issue feels like a clear stepping-stone to the next, and all of them together form a path through the woods to some great destination only Snyder knows about. In short, Snyder is very much a student of the decompression school of comic book writing, which is not a bad thing if you’re diverted enough along the way.
Snyder’s sprightly writing ability will keep you occupied most of the time—how can you not appreciate lines like, “You like the way the foxfire makes the bayou glow at night”? But great prose can’t always disguise the fact that there’s not a whole lot going on. This series has always struggled to fill the pages with its tiny cast (with only two regular characters and perhaps the same number of recurring ones) and its one plotline. Unlike the hive of activity over in its sister title, Animal Man, you rarely get an opportunity to break away from the main event.
The only way Snyder compensates for this is by infusing his story with so much tension that you don’t feel the need for diversion. And it doesn’t get more tense than your hero making a last stand alone against the vastly superior forces of his enemies, among whom the love of his life just happens to be included. While the fate of Abby looked pretty bleak last issue, we all knew Alec would find a way to recover her somehow, though it’s a bit surprising it happens so soon. Seems a waste of a long, traumatic transformation, if you ask me.
Snyder also employs a rather fancy bit of retroactive tweaking to make it happen. Yes, it’s true Alec did say he “freshened” up those peaches back in #5, but at the time we saw no sign of vanilla seeds, or vanilla orchids, or vanilla of any kind, nor even a mention of them. So while it’s a cool detail, and much credit goes to Snyder for making use of it, it also feels haphazardly thrown in. At least it’s proof of why the Green is so important in this war; the Rot seems to have little problem affecting the flesh, but plant life throws it for a loop, apparently.
The question, now, of course, is where Swamp Thing and Orchid Abby (as I’ve taken to calling her) go from here. Certainly neither of them can go back to their ordinary lives—that ship has pretty much sailed. The question is particularly acute for Abby since she’s obviously aligned herself against the Rot, yet she can still command its powers. And now that a bit of the Green seems permanently affixed to her, how will that play out in her future development?
The most disturbing moment of the issue doesn’t pop out at you at first, but once you finish reading it may creep on you: the fate of William Arcane, Abby’s half-brother, whom we’ve kind of forgotten amidst all the hubbub. Abby and Alec pretty much limp off together and leave the kid there, him blubbering and muttering in a worrisome way: “I’m here, my lord. I’ll listen forever. Forev…” If Abby didn’t mean to abandon him before, she can’t say the same now.
Paquette, as always, delivers a dazzling book. Rudy, on his own merits, isn’t deficient, but when you look at his work side-by-side with his partner’s, you can clearly see how it lacks the lushness, the depth, the boldness, the sheer beauty and logical flow of Paquette’s art. Who else could have drawn Rot Queen Abby with such convincing majesty and horror? And Fairbairn hasn’t received nearly enough praise (from me) for his textural coloring; you can actually see the different hues of wood streaking through every crevice and gnarl of Swamp Thing’s skin.
Conclusion: Just as fascinating now as when it first came out, but Snyder’s slow and steady style, along with the narrow focus of the story, makes you feel a bit starved for more substance.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: And the award for Most Ridiculous Sounding Lines Out of Context goes to Rot Queen Abby: “The peaches…you did something!”
Grade
Conclusion