
By: Scott Snyder (writer), Greg Capullo (pencils), Jonathan Glapion (inks), FCO Plascencia (colors), Richard Starkings & Jimmy Betancourt (letters), Katie Kubert (assistant editor) & Mike Marts (editor)
The Fall of the House of Wayne Back-up: Snyder & James Tynion IV (writers), Rafael Albuquerque (art), Dave McCaig (colors), Patrick Brosseau (letters), Kubert & Marts (editors)
The Story: How will Batman deal with a Batcave full of Owls?
Review: This is a hard issue to review because of the expectations heaped on this creative team. They have been SO good throughout this run (and on other projects over the years) that the reader starts to expect “issue of the year” excellence every time. It’s a case of becoming a victim of your own success.
So, my initial reaction to this issue was: “not everything I wanted it to be”. But, then as I reread it a second and third time (which I almost never do), I started to appreciate that even though this isn’t the best comic this creative team has produced, it’s still probably better than every other comic I’ll read this week. It’s like an NBA playoff game where Michael Jordan didn’t have his best game, but still got 22 points and was the best player on the court, and his team still won.
One complaint is the “event”. I’m usually the compulsive dude who buys all the tie-ins and then complains because I felt like the Captain Bogus miniseries (written by Joe Hack and illustrated by No-Fingers-Johnny) was nothing but a shameless money-grab. But, for Night of the Owls, I’m only getting Batman. I like the story for Night of the Owls, but I’m not buying the tie-ins. If Snyder and Capullo told the complete story, I’d buy it in a heartbeat, but I have no interest in buying a bunch of issues by lesser creators. We always hear about events, “You don’t have to buy everything. You can just buy the main series and it’ll read fine.” But, that isn’t really true, is it? We get that one double-pager (with the super-awesome looking new Batmobile) and it shows us Robin, Batgirl and Nightwing fighting the Talons. For me, that popped the bubble. Now I feel like fundamental parts of the story MAY be happening in those other series. But I also know I probably won’t enjoy all of those issues.
Events are very flawed ways to tell a story where the reader is continually in a damned-if-you-do-damned-if-you-don’t position.
The other bother in this issue was the scene with Lincoln March. What happened? Batman walks in, a gun goes off and suddenly there is a dead Talon on the floor and March has a knife buried in his chest. It may be THE pivotal scene of the issue, but when I can’t figure out the flow of action in a scene, it really bothers me and kinda taints an entire issue. I reread this scene about 20 times and I THINK that the Talon was behind the door when Batman came in and March shot the Talon just as the Talon threw the knife… And Batman really had nothing to do with the action? But, if the point of the scene was to mortally wound March so he’d do a deathbed confession with Batman, why bother with the unclear gunshot sequence? Couldn’t the story work fine if Batman just came upon a wounded March? Neither Snyder nor Capullo are wasteful storytellers, so I must have missed something.
Okay, now that I’ve spent paragraphs ripping on this issue, let’s explain why it still gets a high grade and still might be “issue of the week”.
- Look at those Talons in the Batcave! Holy crap are they great. You have to look at the scenes twice, because your initial focus is on the Bat-armor and the armor kinda lessens Capullo’s action drawing capabilities. But the Talons are incredible, especially the top panel on Page 7 where the Talons are standing over Bruce. Look at the energy and malice coming from their body language in a quiet panel.
- Speaking of the Bat-armor, it is amazing how much energy Capullo still manages to get from Batman even when he’s wearing armor. For me, Capullo’s greatest gift is his ability to draw convincing action scenes, so the Bat-armor does kinda neuter him a little. But he drags more out of this bad situation than most artists would.
- The cool new Batmobile! If I were the automotive consultant, I might shorten the nose a tiny bit, but it looks sweet! It looks like it’s covered in sharp edges.
- Enjoy the continuing Bats vs. Owls motif that Snyder is playing with.
- LOVE the idea that Batman is coming for the Owls in the final panel. First he had to survive the maze and escape. Then he had to survive the invasion of the Batcave and Wayne Manor and drive the Owls out. Now he’s going to bring the pain. I LOVE issues where the hero goes on the attack and hopefully that’s what we get in Batman #10.
As for the back-up story, it’s still too soon to tell. Albuquerque’s art is splendid, but anyone who is reading American Vampire already knew that (and if you aren’t reading AV, why not?).
Conclusion: A few hiccups, but still a pretty fine issue.
Grade: B+
-Dean Stell
Follow Dean on Twitter.
Grade
Conclusion