
By: Jeff Lemire (story), Mikel Janín (art), Ulises Arreola (colors)
The Story: Once again, we learn that only horrible things happen in the jungle.
The Review: Considering the excitement I had when this series first launched, it felt almost painful when I ultimately decided to drop it. Not to rehash old grievances, but the series at the time lacked focus, plain and simple. Most of the cast had little to nothing to do, and the plot often wandered erratically. Peter Milligan seemed so focused on fulfilling some abstract conception of “darkness” that he neglected character work and story development entirely.
While Lemire has been slightly overshadowed by his brother-in-arms at DC, Scott Snyder, no one can deny he is just as responsible for the new creative life coursing through the publisher’s veins at the moment. From both Animal Man and Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E., we know he never lets tone or theme dictate the substance of his stories. He builds his characters and plot first, and eventually, overarching motifs reveal themselves, giving the series unity.
His first issue on this series follows this trend, emphasizing the “Justice League” part of the title rather than “Dark.” Lemire gathers an interesting set of heroes together—or rather, a “band,” seeing that’s how Constantine views the team—and almost immediately lets them wail loose on a big mission which only grows bigger as the story goes on. We get no morose monologues or angst-ridden lines; instead, we get clear, distinct personalities which spark against each other.
Lemire simply gets these people in a way Milligan never did. Not only do they work with formidable competence (which was terribly lacking when Milligan wrote the series), you can actually recognize them as the characters you know and love. John’s self-description as band manager goes very true to his traditional portrayal; he’d much rather get others to do his dirty work than go spell-crazy himself. Zee comes across strong, sensible, and loyal, her heart on her sleeve even as she scolds John for his misdeeds. Boston’s irreverent humor (to John: “Stuff it, Cigarette Lad.”) returns in this issue, putting aside all the acidic sarcasm he had before.
In some cases, Lemire has to do quite a bit of back-tracking to return characters to their original, appealing selves, particularly with Madame Xanadu. In the first five issues, she was fractured and disturbed to the point of hysteria, hardly the cool fortune teller we expect. Here, Xan has gotten her quiet arrogance back, dismissing John’s request for aid, though not without a certain amount of hypocrisy, given her past manipulations of the team: “It’s always the same old story with you…everyone who gets close to you pays a price. Well, I’m done with your games.”
We also get a pretty juicy quest for the team to tackle, not only rescuing a fellow mystic and A.R.G.U.S. operative (thus cleverly bringing the JLD closer to the JL proper), but also seeking out the very sources of magic itself. The only question you have to ask is: if Faust had the “eight-dimensional map” in his possession and was siphoning power from it, why didn’t he use it to find his way to the “Books of Magic!” himself?
Janin does fine work, but it all looks quite a bit stiffer and posed than I’d like. His photorealistic style comes at the price of lost detail, with many panels offering no more than a couple figures and a colored background. At times, he doesn’t have the firmest grasp on context. In one panel, he draws Zee looking shocked when the team discovers Faust’s secret weapon, indicating she recognizes it, yet two panels later, she asks John what the object is.
Conclusion: It seems fitting that I repeat a statement I made on another Justice League title and say that this is what the series should’ve been from the very start. Let’s hope it doesn’t come too late.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Raise your hand if you desperately wish Ryan Sook could go beyond his stunning covers and do some interiors for this series. Sook is one of DC’s top-tier artists, but sadly, his top-tier work requires far more time and effort than an ongoing schedule allows.
– Maybe it’s my having recently seen The Avengers, but come on—a glowing cube which is synonymous with a “tesseract”?
– In response to the team name of Justice League Dark, John scoffs, “That is the stupidest name I’ve ever heard.” A thousand points for John—and for Lemire, for calling it like it is.
Grade
Conclusion