
By: Kevin Eastman & Tom Waltz (story), Dan Duncan (art), Ronda Pattison (colors)
The Story: He may be a humanoid rat, but he’s not the biggest rat at this showdown.
The Review: Maybe it’s just me, but I’ve always found the Turtles to be pretty lighthearted fare. When you have a bunch of overgrown reptiles wielding traditional Eastern weaponry while chowing down on pizza…yeah, I’d say you have good reason to believe the story can’t be all that serious. But in this series, Eastman-Waltz have crafted a tale that, while it retains all the silliness and charm that made it a hit, clearly wants to be taken as pure entertainment.
Part of their efforts includes portraying the Turtles as more dimensional individuals than ever before. Understand, each of the brothers has always had his respective interests and personality which prevented him from being a total clone of the others. But only in this series have they been refined such that their voices sound completely credible—human, as it were. You might even say that their mutant, turtley nature has largely become irrelevant, which is nothing short of a major accomplishment, all things considering.
If you can somehow blind yourself enough to read the script of the issue without seeing what’s actually going on, you’ll notice how natural and easy the dialogue reads, despite its ridiculous context (“Mikey fought a bunch of thugs stealing irradiated materials…” “And hung out with a super-hot girl in a catsuit!” “…and Raph slugged it out with a genetically mutated snow fox?”). The Turtles no longer have to fall back on flash-in-the-pan lingo to tell themselves apart; you can identify which one is speaking almost solely by their manner and rhythm.
That’s why their fight in April’s van has some genuine tension to it, enough to pose some real concern over their unity in the future. Leo, Donnie, and Raph are clearly locked in a power struggle at the moment, each essentially representing a different component of leadership (principle, logic, and boldness, respectively). For that reason, they all seem equally worthy of heading the group—and I’m including Mikey, who strives to stay above the fray, but finally speaks up as the voice of practicality.
The solid character work extends beyond our quartet of stars, as well. Krang hasn’t lost any of his blind ambitions, but he’s less ridiculous and more centered, and that makes him a more believable villain. In many other incarnations, I’m sure he’d have already bumped off Stockman for this most recent failure, but instead, he’s content to stand back and mock his contractor. For that matter, all our villains haven’t come across so well in a while. Stockman’s intensity as he rages at Hob gives him some much needed edge to his otherwise average appearance, and certainly Master Shredder, in comparison to his cartoon incompetence, seems like world domination isn’t completely beyond him.
More and more, Duncan seems like a godsend for this series, as he brings just as much credibility to the title’s look as Eastman-Waltz do for the title’s story. Action scenes are clean and punchy; the panel of Splinter latching onto his executioner’s face with his clawed feet from midair, his katana raised high, definitely pops out at you. And I particularly enjoy how much range of expression he gives to a turtle’s face. My only complaint is he lacks consistency in his figures, so at times characters look radically different from panel to panel (check out April’s alienish, wide-set eyes on page 15).
Conclusion: So thoughtfully crafted in both writing and art that you can upgrade this title from “guilty pleasure” to pure “pleasure.”
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Gross and creepy as it may be, but I have to confess I’m digging the vibe I’m getting between Leo and April. But for Leo’s amphibious anatomy, I’d be rooting for a romantic thread way, way down the line.
Grade
Conclusion