
By: Paul Cornell (story), Ryan Kelly (art), Giulia Brusco & Lee Loughridge (colors)
The Story: There’s more than one way for an alien to be a Predator.
The Review: I’ve hinted at this from the start, but Saucer Country, when you think about it, works with a lot of clichés. The aliens in particular are a callback to the hysterical imaginings of the nineties, but many other parts of the story also draw from certain tropes of the genre, whether it be the feverish conflicts between believers and skeptics, or the deepening suspicion that the government and other entities know more about the foreign visitors than they ever let on.
This issue very nearly falls into that hole of the overdone when Michael recalls his hypnotically recovered memories of “the abduction” for Arcadia and her team to hear. Every part of his tale can be linked back to one common conspiracy theory or another, the tired invention of paranoid who has long ceased to even strike doubt into people’s hearts. Remember, though: Cornell plays on all this with a lot of self-awareness; his goal isn’t to make you believe Michael’s story, but to remind you why those stories propagated and struck our consciousness in the first place.
Nowhere does that come through more clearly than in Michael’s terrified recollection of his abuse at the visitors’ hands. Alien rape has become a laughable byproduct of the abduction story, amusing us for its ludicrousness and sheer lack of sense. What tends to be lost amidst the chuckles and sneers is the victim’s trauma of the experience. Whether real or imagined, rape is universally frightening, and Michael’s panicked response to what he believes happened to him is very convincing, calling us out on our own blasé reaction: “[People] laugh because if they took it seriously—they couldn’t stand it…I don’t know why they did it. But it wasn’t funny!”
But what really makes the scene worth believing are everyone else’s reactions, with surprises all over the place. Who’d think the intensely intellectual Kidd would have some an intolerant rage lurking in that professorial frame (“You’re incredibly prone to suggestion, and that makes you useless!”)? Or that Chloe, though still dismissive of all the crazier parts of Michael’s story, would have a compassionate side to her (“No—I don’t think rape is funny,” she tells him, then accusing the others, “You’re not listening to the real story he’s trying to—”)?
Compare these people’s practical deconstruction to the near-fanatical Dr. Glass and his even more paranoid pal Milton (who gets two knocks against his credibility already, one for his ridiculous flaming asteroid shirt and cowboy hat outfit, and another for the ridiculous name). And compare the conspiracy evangelists to the Bluebirds, self-described engineers who believe in the aliens, but with no reverence, fear, or even wonder. This is an ideologically loaded book, and we all know nothing results in greater bloodshed than the war of ideas.
Kelly brings this classic soap opera comic strip aesthetic to the title that calls to mind an updated Mary Worth or Judge Parker, brimming with highly potent emotions. What keeps it from crossing over into melodrama is that no matter how powerfully the characters react, you can sense the enormous self-restraint they operate under. You can see the uncertainty and caution in their expression, the tightness in their faces even as they’re screaming. These are the faces of people who have no wish to give way to their feelings, but can’t help themselves.
Conclusion: An issue which shifts seamlessly between fevered imaginings and cold realities, never letting you decide which is dominant. Ruthlessly fascinating stuff.
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – One thing to watch out for: the presidential security team. It’s no coincidence their sunglasses give off a clear resemblance to alien eyes.
– Then again, their dialogue is very decidedly un-alien: “Fausto—if I may call you Fausto—or, if I may not, because honestly? Fuck you.”
Grade
Conclusion