
By: Geoff Johns (story), Jim Lee (pencils), Scott Williams, Mark Irwin, Jonathan Glapion (inks), Alex Sinclair, Gabe Eltaeb, Tony Avina, Hi-Fi (colors)
The Story: You don’t just break into the Justice League’s clubhouse and get away with it.
The Review: Before I get into the review, I have to apologize for the huge delay on my end this week. As you may know, this gig isn’t my day job. During the summer, I did take on quite a few new commitments that have eaten a lot of time, and this week was an especially rough example of that. I can’t tell you much about the details, but I will say that while it sucked having to put the reviews on hold, it was completely worth it; we got the kid home.
And with that nugget of vagary, let’s talk about what’s really important here: people with superpowers wearing costumes. Up to perhaps last issue, that was pretty much the extent of character development on the League. Aside from a lot of buddy-idiot exchanges between Flash and Green Lantern, with a grumbling Batman in the background, we haven’t really seen this set of extraordinary individuals mesh together as a cohesive team just yet.
That doesn’t exactly happen in this issue either, but now you see them taking those baby steps to realizing they can’t just band up every couple weeks and remain total strangers to each other. From their little campfire session here, you can see the rudiments of an office dynamic forming: cliques within the clique, bits of common knowledge, personal remarks and questions that you can tell want to go a little deeper than they do. In short, this is a group of people still learning where the boundaries are with each other.
It’s unclear, at any rate, how much they really want to know about each other, and more importantly how much they want to reveal to each other. Aquaman questions, “How are we supposed to be a team if our enemies know more about us than we do?” He’s not talking about their individual power sets or their physical strengths or witnesses. He’s really talking about the League’s lives outside of “work,” information you reserve only for those you trust the most. So his query is not how much they know each other, but how much they trust each other.
Those issues are all old beef for the team. In comparison to Tower of Babel, which was a true example of League betrayal and suspicion, the tension here lacks urgency. Maybe because most of the tidbits Cyborg uncovers seems so inconsequential (“Superman’s a reporter?”). And maybe because Graves doesn’t really use the information he’s gathered to strike down the team, relying instead on some supernatural kind of power to play on their deepest losses.
Lee has a monotonously attractive style of art, the equivalent of seeing a million runway models in a row, each a near-copy of the other, with no variation except in their outer wear. Looking at the League’s intimate conversation on the Watchtower, it’s amazing how little of their internal emotions come through. This makes sense, I suppose; they appear as guarded as they behave. But it makes for a bland flavor of drama, again showing Lee’s deficiency in subtlety.
In contrast, Gary Frank puts in so much attention to the direction and acting in the scenes that they resonate as if you’re there, watching it all happen before your eyes. But give credit where it’s due, because Frank works off a pretty solid script here. The back-and-forth between Freddy and Billy have a lot of the naturalism that made Johns’ work on Teen Titans so powerful; to some degree, I’m far more interested in the straight drama of Billy’s civilian life than in whether he becomes the big-chested marvel he’s destined to be.
Conclusion: It’s always a mixed bag with this title, isn’t it? While the “SHAZAM!” back-up gains momentum, the main feature loses a bit of steam, making for an underwhelming read overall.
Grade: B-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Hold on—since Batman mentions Captain Cold as one of the villains Graves interrogates, I’m assuming Cold’s the one who revealed Flash’s police connections. But how did Cold learn that kind of stuff in the first place?
Grade
Conclusion