By: Kevin Eastman & Tom Waltz (story), Dan Duncan (art), Ronda Pattison (colors)

The Story: As they say, an rat is hard to kill–especially one with a katana.

The Review: Everything I know about the Turtles, I know from the 80s cartoon.  Not only that, but I was limited to the seven or eight rerun episodes that my family randomly recorded with a third-tier VCR.  (A VCR, kids, is a video cassette recorder and I’ll only describe it by saying that they were inconvenient and fragile in every way short of being just reels of film in your hand, and yay for Blu-rays.)  So it’s safe to say my knowledge of TMNT continuity has limits.

And it’s with no little surprise and delight that I encounter each additional character Eastman-Waltz add to the series.  It’s good to know that the Turtles’ world extends beyond them fighting a thousand robot Foot Soldiers each episode, or watching Bebop and Rocksteady fail in some raucously amusing way once again.  This time around, we get the Purple Dragons, a gang from Joe Casey’s leg of the woods who aren’t too happy about four oversized reptiles moving in on their turf, in addition to all the other ninja, mutant or otherwise, hanging around.

As is, the Purple Dragons don’t illicit much more than vague interest from you.  They don’t have much apparent personality other than good intentions under a gruff demeanor (Angel, the leader, describes themselves as “a crew.  Like, community watch.”).  That doesn’t mean they won’t capture your heart somewhere down the line, but for now, it’s enough to have them around as an excuse to see gangbangers team up with the Turtles in defeating invading ninja in the ‘hood.

At the end of the day, this issue is largely an excuse to see some stupendously silly and enjoyable sights, like Splinter single-handedly taking down every single acolyte of the Foot Clan, knocking out Apolex (the fox ninja) in one-on-one combat, cutting off Karai’s arrow in midair, and challenging Shredder to a duel to the death.  This is all good times, but it doesn’t actually move the story forward in any substantial way, and mostly we retread the same plot points we’ve covered many times before (i.e. past lives, reincarnation, revenge, honor, etc.).

If there’s any depth to be had from this issue, it might come from Splinter’s determination to win the day, not just to exact vengeance on the man who murdered his family, but also to return to his family.  I always find it touching when people fight for nothing more than simply to see their loved ones again, a far more relatable goal than all the ideals people claim to fight for.  Hokey as it is to say, the father-sons relationship here may be the true heart that makes this series so great.  For some reason, such unadulterated displays of affection are rarities in the cynical world of comics, so it’s a breath of fresh air to see the Turtles and Splinters so devoted to each other.

Duncan has a lot of action choreography to manage in this issue, and it seems to overwhelm him a bit.  While he pulls off each sequence without any obvious deficiencies, they don’t have quite the punch previous issues had.  Splinter alone versus the horde of Foot Clan ninja should be a much more elaborate battle, but it mostly comes down to four panels of Splinter spinning about, with a minimal display of his skills.  Same thing with Splinter’s fight with Apolex; had it been just one or the other, a whole issue could have been devoted to Splinter’s mastery, but with both, the truncated scenes make the conflict seem too straightforward.

Conclusion: Thin on the plot, but chock full of fun imagery and really, isn’t that what TMNT are all about?

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – There is no way that one measly pizza could possibly serve four hungry, possibly still growing turtles.  I’m pretty sure the cartoon Turtles could’ve had a pizza that size each to himself.

– And not to belabor the comparisons with the cartoon, but will ever see April’s van converted to a mobile base of operations, you think?

Grade

Conclusion