By: James Robinson (story), Frazer Irving (art)

The Story: By now, the Shade views restraints as nothing more than foreplay.

The Review: In my estimation, Robinson runs middle of the road when it comes to the sheer originality of his ideas.  If Geoff Johns basically takes classic yarns and makes them like new, while Grant Morrison continually spins new concepts and structures in comic book storytelling, then Robinson does something in between: he’ll take an old concept and buff it up, add his own zany take on things, but he doesn’t quite play any of it out in a radical way.

I think we can all agree that if nothing else, Robinson has made Shade a powerfully compelling figure, which is an impressive step up for an obscure Justice Society (sigh—remember them?) villain.  And certainly, Robinson hasn’t exactly been lacking in unusual material (e.g. religious vampire vigilante in Spain, cosmic Egyptian gods enslaved by a cabal of naked businessmen, etc.).  But he has a bit of difficulty pulling off a climax or resolution that truly surprises you.

Certainly all the pieces are in place for an outstanding ender—and we may still get one—but this issue pans out pretty much along predictable lines.  The moment you learn Miles and Dudley somehow made those gods subservient to them, you know those gods will get free and wreak havoc at some point.  And just as soon as Shade pulls out some hidden tricks, forcing Miles to assert more effort to contain our hero, you know how those gods will find their freedom.  It’s such child’s play that you Miles and Dudley seem like simpletons for not realizing it sooner.

But then they are so very simple, these “villains.”  They have no lofty ambitions, just pure greed and an intolerable sense of self-importance.  They revel in some of the most despicable acts and markets in the world (“Drugs.  Arms.  Children.  Germs”—not to mention terrorism and human sacrifice) without any particular reason to except because they enjoy being the total scum of the earth.  Sadder still, both turn out rather impotent once their secret weapons go away, and as a result, feel like poor antagonists for the Shade to end on.

In terms of sheer power, those Egyptian “gods” make perfect opponents for the Shade.  But we all know the heart of this series hasn’t been about Shade’s abilities, but about his heart and soul, and the gods’ unthinking malice do nothing to challenge Shade in that regard.  It’s disappointing that Robinson doesn’t take advantage of our hero’s temporary helplessness in a way that shows Shade’s true mettle, without the shadowy distractions.  But at the least, we see that the man known as Richard Swift may do evil things, but not because he’s an evil person.  He freely admits to his crimes, but makes it clear he doesn’t commit them purely for fun.

Irving has a knack for shaping faces you immediately want to punch.  The smarmy sneers on Miles and Dudley have the effect of instantly filling you with rage, and when their cockiness gets replaced with fear and horror, it fills you with positive delight.  But Irving covers a pretty wide range of emotion, though almost always in his distinctly exaggerated way.  When Shade shows disappointment, the look on his face verges on dismay, quite in contrast to his usual composure.

Conclusion: Quite a lot of talking and not much doing, but with Shade, even sheer chatter can be fascinating.  Besides, Robinson sets things up to make the final two issues a blowout of godlike scale.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Again, I’m always fascinated by masters trusting their servants to perform their most crucial tasks for them.  What exactly stops Carmichael from getting sick of Miles’ lip and commanding the gods to smash Miles?

Grade

Conclusion