
By: Paul Cornell (story), Ryan Kelly (art), Giulia Brusco (colors)
The Story: This is a long, long way from the late act of a high school grad night.
The Review: I don’t know what this world is coming to. Without naming names, I often look at the TV personalities frequenting the airwaves, unleashing loose opinions and unsubstantiated ideas with a delivery that borders on frantic, yet somehow drawing a ton of people into their larger-than-life mania. I don’t know how folks get suckered into such a ridiculous worldview yet simultaneously scoff alien conspiracy theorists because in my mind, there’s no difference.
Do you know why we all brush off the UFO-heads as crazy people? Because with few exceptions, they act like crazy people, either strident to the point of violence, or so deadly convinced of their erroneous logic that it’s frightening. You can pity these people, but you can’t take them seriously.
And that’s exactly why when Arcadia states that the truth is out there—a cliché phrase, to be sure, but apropos in this case, I think—we tend to believe her. She speaks with conviction, but as much as to the holes in her understanding as to what she understands: “I can’t claim to have uncovered any truths while hypnotized—I think all it gave us was some…clues. Some pointers.” She uses the gaps in her knowledge to demand greater investigation, to uncover whether anything she experienced makes actual sense.
Strangely, her own delusions warn her not to trust everything she sees. A “silver woman” with a vague resemblance to the governor herself shows up at Arcadia’s greatest moment of distress, reassuring her that the whole universe hasn’t become a playground for the aliens to do with as they please, “and this isn’t the whole truth. Some of this memory is a metaphor. Some of it is art. All of it is real. None of it is meaningless.”
Distinguishing what from what, of course, will be the hard part, but suddenly, that process seems just as exciting as it does to Kidd. Like us, he fixates on the discrepancies from the usual sightings tales, eager to discover if they will lead to a realm of stories we’ve never heard before. Meanwhile, Chloe remains the indispensable skeptic, while Harry swears loyalty to Arcadia no matter where the truth lies—and gains our hearts in the process. “I’ve never hugged you, have I?” she realizes. “And this new guy gets his right away,” Harry grumbles. “Story of my life.”
In short, Cornell has right under our noses produced not only a campaign-winning team, but a rock-solid ensemble cast, each member with a crucial role, an unlikely mix of personalities that will have to face all obstacles together. And they have much to face: nut-jobs who will stop at nothing to accomplish their goals, secret societies of hyper-intellectuals, military circles within the government. The possibilities are endless, aren’t they?
Once again I’m struck by the masterful way Kelly handles the extraterrestrial matter in this series. The aliens look eerily graceful, but threatening in their emaciation, a starved, twisted reflection of the human form. Kelly also proves a master of human expression, turning up the knob on every emotion without once letting it go over the top, keeping the paranoia thick in the air without making you so aware of it that it becomes comical.
Conclusion: Cornell has taken a worn-out storyline and given it so much substance that an online review is barely adequate to scratch the surface of intrigue in store. That by itself deserves our respect.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Incidentally, although I’m eighty percent sure hypnotism is a crock of shizz, I have enough doubt about it that I will never let myself get caught alone with a hypnotist—ever.
– Dr. Glass’ flip-off of Arcadia’s NDA just goes to show: the law’s punitive value doesn’t do a damn thing if you just don’t care.
– “So, please, kids, shut the fuck up—or we are not going to Six Flags.” Harry may be my new hero.
Grade
Conclusion