
By: Geoff Johns (story), Jim Lee (pencils), Scott Williams & Jonathan Glapion (inks), Alex Sinclair & Gabe Eltaeb (colors)
The Story: Even Wonder Woman can get a little touchy about her love life.
The Review: The creative supervisors at DC aren’t totally blind, right? If so, then I can only assume that the uptick in superheroes’ parental deaths post-relaunch must be a purposeful decision of some kind. In the last year, Cyborg lost his mother (presumably), Wonder Woman lost hers, and Superman lost both his parents. We’re not even yet counting the Green Lantern, the Flash, Aquaman, and of course Batman’s traditionally deceased parentage.
This trend is so ludicrously prevalent that I feel safe in calling it a cheap gimmick, a crutch to give characters an air of tragedy that tries to pull itself off as depth. But horribly cynical as this sounds, death has little meaning unless it has the weight of a life behind it. For the newly orphaned members of the League, we have no true conception of what the deaths of their parents mean to them except that they’re sad, an obvious statement that hardly moves you personally.
At least these deaths serve as a handy common ground for the League, though they don’t really know it yet. Two issues which continue to plague them even now have been their general lack of closeness and trust. While respect abounds among them, they have little interest in forging relationships deeper than that (save for the always classic Superman-Batman and Green Lantern-Flash duos). Their visions of loved ones passed guarantee a “coming out” scene in the near future, one that will undoubtedly give them the trust they need to operate as a real team.
In the meantime, it’s not clear exactly what Graves wants from the League, either to destroy them or to simply destroy their credibility. The latest update on his family tragedy doesn’t really clear up the matter, as there’s a cratering disconnect between what happened to his wife and kids and the League itself. This reduces Graves to your run-of-the-mill crazy-pants seeking revenge from all the wrong places, hardly a breakthrough in villain construction.
Johns doesn’t do a much better job when it comes to fleshing out our heroes. His portrayal of Wonder Woman has been particularly problematic, and even here, where she takes some center focus, Johns doesn’t succeed in giving us a deeper glimpse into her inner self. Instead, he falls back on her one unchangeable trait: her kickassery. Satisfying as it is to see her smash through powerhouses Green Lantern and Superman, you don’t quite understand her any better afterward.
Lee begins to slip just the tiniest bit from his ever-reliable angular lines. Towards the end of the issue, you can’t help noticing the eyes going a bit more doe-like and watery, the facial features more blunted, looking like Andy Kubert briefly took the drawing reins. Still, that splash of Wonder Woman dismissively shattering Hal’s constructs (bloodying his face in the process) has the energy and impact worthy of the big screen.
The piecemeal approach to SHAZAM! really doesn’t work that well. With character-driven tales like this, Johns really needs some time to build up momentum, and just as he does so, the feature ends, leaving you frustrated and unsatisfied (cue the sexual quips here). At any rate, you’re less interested in the cliffhangers left behind, since most of us know this origin story pretty well, and more interested in finding out how everyone will react once Billy manages to get home. Again, major kudos to Gary Frank and Brad Anderson for keeping this little story alive by sheer artistic merit alone.
Conclusion: Still one of the most mediocre anchor titles being published, a series which continues to struggle for relevance.
Grade: C+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – I’m a bit disheartened to find that Wonder Woman’s sword is not even a little bit magical, as Superman was able to grab the blade with his bare hand with no effect.
Grade
Conclusion