By: You know the drill—IMDB it.

The Story: Batman trades in one God-forsaken hellhole for another.

The Review: To use a handy legal term of art, I join with Ramon in his overall opinion about this much-anticipated film, but I’d like to clarify what makes The Dark Knight Rises both satisfying and disappointing at the same time.  Ultimately, the movie successfully closes out director Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy on a high note, but not quite as high as the dizzying peak that was The Dark Knight.  What this film suffers from is mostly a case of bad timing.

Without giving anything away, plot-wise, Rises at its core is a story about how much one man can accomplish if he has the right drive.  There really isn’t much difference between the Batman who starts the film and the one who finishes it; what the initial Batman lacks, and what leads to his downfall, is his strength of spirit.  Kudos to Christian Bale for getting this across through sheer presence, because you can clearly sense Bruce in the first act of the film, despite his drive and ferocity, going through the motions.  If he manages to turn things around by the final act, it’s from understanding the value of his life anew, not from his affinity with death.

By the standard of superhero movies, this is a strong message, well expressed without being preachy.  It also allows Bruce’s story to fade out on an uplifting coda, on a chord of hope, which is what Batman essentially represents to Gotham and to his audience, regardless of his grim imagery and manner.  A dark one, he may be, but he is still a knight, one who stands for the best in people.  And for that reason, Bruce deserves a closing that gives him a little hope as well.

So in one sense, the sense where this is final chapter of an intensely dramatic, character-driven story, Rises does everything it should do to leave fans at peace.  In another sense, the sense where this is the final chapter of an intensely ambitious, idea-driven story, Rises fails to recapture the complex savor and vision of its predecessor.

When you consider The Dark Knight, the real climax of that film wasn’t when Joker and Batman’s verbal or physical battle, nor even Harvey Dent’s twisted execution scene.  The moment which truly encapsulated that movie’s whole purpose was when the ferry passengers refused to murder each other.  In that moment, Gotham saved itself by showing, in just about the most inspiring fashion possible, that there is good within even the very worst of itself.  In contrast, Rises paints the people of Gotham as victims once more, sheep who need batarang-wielding, kung fu-fighting shepherds to come to their rescue.

Furthermore, in contrast to Heath Ledger’s Joker, who seemed less of a mortal man and more like an avatar of chaos in The Dark Knight, Tom Hardy’s Bane has so much physical and intellectual presence that you never lose sight of his earthly makeup, monstrous as he seems.  And while Anne Hathaway’s Selina Kyle is lip-licking luscious in both body language and charm, she can’t possibly serve as the tortured foil Aaron Eckhart’s Two-Face was.  On this and so many other levels, Rises simply doesn’t have the epic, eternal qualities that Dark Knight did, even to the very settings.  The pristine yet Gothic architectural landscape of Chicago served very well as the legendary kingdom for the Dark Knight, while Rises plays out as a large-scale—but inescapably grounded—drama in the urban confines of Pittsburgh.

Conclusion: While mostly muddled in regards to its core themes and motifs, The Dark Knight Rises ultimately keeps your attention fixed and delivers a story that will stay with you far longer than all the bombastic spectacle of other superhero films.

Grade: A-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – As for the tragedy in Aurora, Colorado, I am as grieved by the needless deaths of the victims as I am amazed by the people who misguidedly blame the content of the Batman movies, rather than the perpetrator’s sadly disturbed mind, for the event.  Remember: Batman hates guns.

Grade

Conclusion