
By: Sam Humphries (story), Ramón Pérez (art), Jordie Bellaire (colors)
The Story: Poor John Carter just can’t manage to keep his wife for long, can he?
The Review: You know one thing the old-timey storytellers knew how to do really well that modern ones either avoid or screw up? They knew how to bring their heroes to the brink of a happy ending, then wrench it away in the most heartrending way possible. It’s a very melodramatic fictional tactic, one that can easily go too far awry, but done right, it packs an emotional wallop. Don’t tell me you saw the ending of Casino Royale without feeling for Bond.
Considering the corny—but tasteful—quality of this mini, you would’ve thought an ending where Carter and Dejah reunite and Issus goes down for good, leaving Barsoom in the light of a new era of pace, was inevitable. But when—spoiler alert—the issue ends and none of those things happen, it leaves you in disbelief and sympathy for our hero. This series has been calling out your inner child and it’s with a child’s disappointment that you go through the conclusion. It’s as if you’re re-experiencing a bittersweet ending for the first time.
And the fact that Issue is still out there, possibly reviving within her tomb, and with Dejah trapped with her for a Barsoomian year, a sense of dread hangs over the issue. That, more than the eye-rolling “The End…?” tells you that we haven’t seen the last of John Carter and his Martian fantasy just yet.
It’s good we have some loose ends to tie up, because every other plot thread gets wrapped up a little too neatly. The final page indeed shows Barsoom about to embark on a “new era,” where all the planet’s various races finally come together in peace. Well, goody for them, I suppose, but the straightforward, highly romanticized, and stupidly simple way that it happens makes the victory feel unearned and a little too easy. Had Humphries given some more specifics to the each race’s animosity towards the other (instead of a series of hierarchal prejudice), you’d be more invested in their unity, but mostly you just shrug.
I suppose, however, that it’s enough simply for all the important characters to survive, including the unfortunate Dejah, and thus hope springs eternal. How can we possibly complain? Originals Carter, Tars Tarkas, Kantos, and Sola live to adventure another day, and new pals Cathoris, Thuvia, and Xodar will stick around, too. Again, it’s that child’s hope and optimism bubbling to the top, making you believe that as long as they’re together, they can do anything.
If we ever return to the world of Barsoom again, I hope Pérez will be there to show it to us. His joy comes clear and true through his art, and you can see it right from the very first page. The fearless grins on our heroes faces as they free-fall through the evening air, bursts of explosions and gunfire around them—just warms your heart, doesn’t it? And with Bellaire’s bold hues popping out at us, it just makes you wish you could, just for one second, step into that exciting, colorful world.
Conclusion: We’ve seen major advances and inspired uses of the comics medium in the last year, but it’s been a while since we’ve experienced the sheer pleasure of it. This mini is a great reminder that comics can succeed simply by making you happy.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Okay, DC editorial, listen to this: Humphries, Pérez, and Bellaire working on a space opera ongoing, something along the lines of Mystery in Space,featuring Adam Strange, Captain Comet, and Tanga/Starfire. How’s that for a pitch?
Grade
Conclusion