By: Bryan Q. Miller (story), Pere Perez (art), Chris Beckett (colors)

The Story: Chloe stares at her own death right in the face.

The Review: As it so happens, when I bought this issue of Smallville, I noticed my comic book shop had a small, prominent display of Marvel’s Ultimate line of books, probably the most substantial investment in an alternate-reality series ever.  After flipping through a few of the trades, I came to Ultimate Spider-Man and realized that no matter how compelling or well-crafted any of these characters will be, no one will ever think of them as the definitive heroes.

So there’s a kind of futility that comes attached to these parallel Earth series.  Granted, no one has established the world of Smallville as an “official” parallel Earth with its own numeric designation in the grand scheme of DC’s Multiverse just yet, but what else can it be?  As a continuing series, it can’t operate under the Elseworlds moniker (if indeed DC ever plans to use that brand again), and it’s certainly not meant to supplant the current Superman in a major way.

For that reason alone, it’s hard to take the series as seriously as it might deserve.  While Miller hasn’t exactly turned it into a runaway hit, in terms of sheer quality, it at least beats the ongoing Superman (and might have beat Action Comics at one point, but for the latter title gaining steam as of late).  Nonetheless, no matter how good an issue of Smallville turns out to be, you tend to come away dismissing it as a fun but irrelevant alternative to what’s already out there.

And if the issues don’t reach stellar levels, and this one does not, then you have even more reason to shrug them off.  The bulk of this month’s action comes from the fight between Superman and the now-robotic Henshaw, but most of it merits only yawns.  Henshaw grows predictably unstable and deranged in realizing what he’s become, blaming one person after another for his current predicament, so of course Superman has to step in and stop that nonsense.

I use the word “nonsense” very purposely here.  As I argued last time, it seems pointless and ridiculous to engage in any finger-pointing for this particular comic book accident.  Lex comes off as slimy and Henshaw’s wife as dimwitted for trying to convince the burned-out astronaut that Superman’s failure to rescue is to blame, rather than Lex’s negligence in building the platform.  Call it his circuited mind, but Henshaw hits the real point right away: “You’re Lex Luthor!  You don’t make mistakes!”

The absence of clarity of thought in that scene almost totally degrades the otherwise solid issue.  Lex sticks it to Superman in a fiendishly clever way, making him seem more diabolical here than he has in any title post-relaunch.  Lex’s evil plan actually succeeds in putting Clark in a kind of helpless position, at least for the next five hundred years, and it’ll at least take some creativity to get our hero out of that spot.  And of course, Oliver and Chloe’s discovery that their stalker comes from way beyond outer space, fleeing from some kind of “crisis,” hints that Miller has big, universe-spanning plans of his own for this series.

Perez puts in a fine effort, but you can’t really escape the fact that this is something less than A-grade art here.  Kudos to him for delivering consistent results each week—a feat certainly all the other A-artists out there would collapse in their own blood, sweat, and tears trying to do—but there’s no denying that in terms of action, emotion, detail, and style, you can name dozens and dozens of artists you do it better and with more personality.

Conclusion: Worthy of attention by pure effort alone, this series clearly wants you to take it seriously and, even more amazingly, succeeds briefly from time to time.

Grade: B-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Apparently, I missed a couple Smallville episodes of some significance, since everyone in this issue doesn’t even flinch at the mention of “the other Earth.”

– Chloe, let your dead counterpart be a lesson to you: going brunette might not be the best choice for you.

Grade

Conclusion