By: Sean Murphy (writer/artist), Todd Klein (letters), Joe Hughes (assistant editor) & Karen Berger (editor)

The Story: Things get a little claustrophobic on the island where the J2 reality show is being filmed.

Review: This is a hard issue to review.  It’s very good, but reviewing it in exacting detail feels a little like reviewing a TV show between the first and second commercial breaks.  At this point, we’ve met the characters and are just watching them settle into their roles so we can grow to like or loathe them more as the story chugs along.

The two characters taking on more interest in this issue are Grace (the mother of J2) and Thomas the head of security.  Thomas is made much more interesting by being more than a hired mercenary.  Perhaps the folks in charge thought they were getting a mere gun-for-hire, but Thomas is a lot more complex than that.  Seeing how deeply he actually seems to care for Grace and J2/Chris, how he’s a man with religious faith and how there are some things he simple won’t do makes him intriguing.  At the same time….although it is tempting to brand him the “hero” of the story, I wouldn’t be too sure.  He’s still not a very nice guy and he might sell our more vulnerable characters out at a key moment.

Actually, this ambiguity is part of the reason I love comics like this.  When I read about Spider-Man or Batman, I know the field of play.  There are certain things those established heroes won’t do under any circumstances, but with Thomas we don’t yet know his limits.  All we know is that he isn’t entirely good or evil.

It’s hard to not feel sorry for Grace.  I guess I hadn’t quite grasped her youth in the first issue.  SIXTEEN?  And not only is she a teenage mother, but she’s living in a fishbowl with a child who is either the second coming or an abomination depending on someone’s point of view?  Can you imagine being a teenage mother and having religious fanatics who want to kill you and your baby?

Which brings us to Slate, the mastermind who is pulling the strings.  What a creep!  Not only has he manipulated this whole thing for profit and caused worldwide angst, but what he’s done to Grace is really sad.  If you wondered why she’s such a cute girl, it’s because Slate wanted her to be that with a nose-job and boob-job.  I guess the mother of J2 must have ample breasts, huh?  On the other hand, at least no one expects Slate to do a good turn for anyone.

And then we have our scientist.  I’m sure that over the course of the series she’ll grow a spine, but so far she’s a fairly typical scientist.  She’ll rationalize just about anything if it gives her funding to do her research.

That’s a pretty rich cast of characters after only two issues and there’s a lot to look forward to in this series.  We still haven’t really seen J2 as anything more than a blob.  We still haven’t seen Thomas make a difficult decision that puts his morals at odds with his paycheck.  We haven’t seen if the good doctor will make a right decision even if it means she loses her research sponsor.  Murphy has done a great job of lining all the characters up for some nice moments……now he just needs to pay them off in interesting ways over the remainder of the series.

Of course, the art is beautiful.  Murphy is a Top 5-10 talent in comics from an artistic standpoint, so you knew it would look good.  For the most part, it’s what you’d expect if you’re a Murphy fan: expressive and slightly cartoony characters matched with exquisitely drawn environments.  He mentioned on Twitter that all of the guns in the series are from various science-fiction movies and that Grace’s house is the Picard homestead from Star Trek: The Next Generation.  I love these sorts of Easter eggs and it really shows Murphy’s dedication.  He could’ve just drawn a house, but instead he found a house that he liked, found the references and drew it.

Conclusion: Murphy has created a bunch of interesting characters and maneuvered them into positions where they’ll have to make some choices.  The rest of this series should be a joy.

Grade: A-

– Dean Stell

Grade

Conclusion