
By: Paul Cornell (story), Jimmy Broxton (art)
The Story: This just proves that the humor of Mork & Mindy is universal—and probably Happy Days too.
The Review: As a title so dedicated to figuring out what’s real and what’s all in a person’s head, it should surprise no one if it reads more cerebrally than your average comic book. Consider this: since the debut, our characters have barely budged—physically—from where they started out. Yet the plot has made major strides in development and given you at least a couple high points of tension, only it’s all mental.
For that reason, if all stories can be boiled down to their essential elements of plot and character, then character would be the crucial focus of this series. Even after six issues, we still don’t know if there’s any truth to this alien hooey. We’ve gotten no surefire manifestation of the paranormal or extraterrestrial. Everything we’ve seen so far has been heavily couched in visions, senses, fragments of memories. The story is, from an outsider’s perspective, still very much grounded in reality, and unlike superhero reality, plot and action don’t change and develop that quickly.
So if we want a sense of movement from the story, we must look to the characters. We have to keep track of shifts in belief and motive, alterations of their behavior. At this point, Arcadia and Co. have all taken a big step forward, whether they realize it or not, in their attitudes toward UFO theory by sitting through an entire lecture on it without much of a scoff.
But then, Professor Kidd makes for an engrossing lecturer. Cornell took a big risk in his exposition-heavy construction of the issue; generally, twenty-something straight pages of information which doesn’t move the story forward has little chance of affecting you. Kidd sucks you into his monologue by appealing to one of our most irresistible impulses: to latch onto and obsess over inexplicable patterns in the seeming random and disconnected. In one fell swoop, he casts religion, the supernatural, science-fiction, and mental disturbance as shades of the same thing. “[T]hey’re all drawn to the gravity of the UFO,” he claims. And so are we, probably.
Kidd makes a stunning intellectual oversight only once, and I’m not even talking about his little mix-up between government cover-up and Ridley Scott. He insists that for the folks who see genuinely unusual things, things that go outside “the monomyth” (a term which I just love on a purely rhetorical level) of alien understanding, are either “lying, or something else is going on. I think something else is going on.” He completely skips over the possibility of mental breaks or delusions, and maybe he does so to avoid hard questions about his own mental soundness.
The name Broxton barely registered—well, didn’t register—when I read it on the credits, but when I saw the rough, almost barky texture to the older male characters’ faces, I flashbacked to Knight and Squire immediately. Unlike the floppy and cartoony figures he drew in that mini (also a collaboration with Cornell), Broxton demonstrates a much more serious side to his art here. The women in particular look fully fleshed and very true to life, and all serious scenes receive the appropriately sober tone—though Broxton displays his usual sense of humor in the final page.
Conclusion: Cornell has been playing this tightrope game of working with cliché while deliberately breaking out of it in the most controlled way possible, and once again, he stays on his toes. A daring issue that just manages to work.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – This makes you wonder, of course, what the aliens thought of Roswell. Do they appreciate millennial teenage angst as much as they do seventies sitcoms?
Grade
Conclusion