By: Scott Snyder (story), Kano (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)

The Story: You ever get the feeling your spouse isn’t acting like herself?

The Review: You may not believe this, but I think I caught on to Harry Potter before pretty much anyone else in my neighborhood.  My middle school library had exactly two copies of the first book, hardbound, with a glossy plastic sheeting they used to cover new books.  Of course, once the floodgates of wizard madness opened, pretty much the only books in the library that anyone actually cared to borrow were Harry Potters, but I digress.

From the very first book, it became obvious that Harry was fated to meet Voldemort again.  I don’t think anyone expected that he’d be confronting Voldemort in practically every single book he starred in, but J.K. Rowling made it clear that was Harry’s destiny as a hero and savior.  In contrast, the Parliament of Trees have made a big fuss over Alec Holland being their legendary warrior-king, but it hasn’t been entirely clear until now how he’d earn that title.  At the end of the day, it was Abby who felled Sethe in #9, not Alec.

This issue reveals that Alec still has a big chance to step up to the plate and prove himself, because Anton Arcane may be his Voldemort.  If Animal Man #0 didn’t already make it clear, Anton seems a bit special even for the lofty standards of avatar status.  Against the collective power and wisdom of the Parliaments of Trees and Totems, he has (it looks like) single-handedly defeated them time and again.  Although Snyder never says as much, Anton’s longevity alludes to the idea that he simply grows stronger with each avatar he kills.

Through Anton, Snyder again proves himself a horror writer of the finest pedigree.  Anton’s ability to take up another person’s skin injects a constant sense of paranoia into the series; you never know where—or in whom—he’ll be lurking.  As the scenes between Alec and his once-wife demonstrate, you can’t suppress a prickly, creeping feeling on your neck thinking how you can be so intimate, so sincerely affectionate to someone who’s planning your death at that very moment.  And if this line isn’t a testament to Snyder’s poetry as a writer, nothing is: “Hey, Lin,” Alec says to his “wife,” “Thanks for being you.”

Speaking of Alec’s wife, this issue has value not only because it catches new readers up to Swamp Thing on his classic origin story, but it also offers a glimpse into Alec’s pre-resurrection days, probably the last time he was ever purely human.  I never really thought about it before, but Alec really is an everyman sort of character without all the Green stuff attached.  The way he interacts with his fellow scientists and his wife, he comes across very distinctly as your average Joe, affectionate and dedicated, with just enough good humor to keep him grounded.  Compared to the angsty individual he started this series as, you feel much more sympathy for him now.

Kano offers a bit of a mixed bag as far as art goes.  Like Marco Rudy, you can clearly tell he’s spending a lot of time trying to emulate Yanick Paquette’s lush, stylish paneling, but his comes off too much like he’s trying to mimic Paquette.  Otherwise, he has a clinically clean approach to drawing his figures that renders the horror that much more intense.  His choice of depicting Anton crushing various Swamp Things’ heads like fruit is perfectly shudder-inducing.

Conclusion: Like Animal Man #0, a careful blend of Vertigo dogma and the modern mythology that Snyder has lain down.  If you don’t take Anton Arcane seriously after this, nothing will change your mind.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – After seeing Anton’s bare-nekkid figure so many times, I have to laugh at the lengths artists will go to make sure his privates are out of sight.  I particularly appreciate that it’s okay to look at a characters full moon of a behind as long as their butt-crack isn’t showing.

Grade

Conclusion