
By: Jim McCann (story), Rodin Esquejo & Adrian Alphona (art), Sonia Oback & Beny Maulana (colors)
The Story: When your dad says he’ll always be watching over you, he probably doesn’t mean it this way.
The Review: I don’t consider myself an elitist where comics are concerned. I’m perfectly happy to indulge in the frequently mindless extravagance and spectacle of superheroes, even when they don’t have much in the way of literary merit. Sometimes, though, it’s a relief to take a break from the “catch the villain”/“save the world” bit in favor of some real, down-to-earth stories. The stakes may be smaller, but they have much more weight.
So after a few days of magic-slinging men in trenchcoats and lost kingdoms under the sea, I was very happy to sit down to the grounded drama of a guy trying to escape his roots. I have to say, the drunk father has become sort of a cliché villain in a lot of stories—the contemporary version of the evil stepmother—but more than abusively inebriated, Dane Miller’s dad is downright malicious. He actively seeks revenge against his son; he gives no special consideration to his relationship with Dane, so he comes across as particularly easy to hate.
Given this kind of background, Dane has an environmental reason for any violent tendencies he might have toward Elle, but this glimpse into his past actually hints that he has nothing of the sort. At one point, he hisses at his dad, “And if you even try to get to her, I’ll finish the job like I should’ve years ago. You’ll be a dead man. When it comes to Elle, I’ll do whatever I have to.” A surface reading of his lines should settle the matter, but upon closer inspection, there’s an ambiguity to that last one that has a threatening ring. We can’t completely abandon the theory that Dane was somehow involved in her attack, but the likelihood seems lower now.
Same goes for Mrs. Peterssen. She may be revealed as the woman behind the curtain, pulling the senior Miller’s strings, but that doesn’t nearly confirm her as the ultimate perp. She could very well be taking advantage of her daughter’s predicament to get rid of some loose ends, but that doesn’t mean she sprung the initial attack—quite. She does reveal, however, that she has a very long reach and thus has the means to execute such a conspiracy. She also reveals a connection to a certain man in a hoodie, one upon whom she doles out some of the warmest language we’ve ever heard her utter: “You have done well. Thank you.” Who could possibly merit such effusive language from the ice queen, I wonder?
This issue is also important in establishing Annie as a character we should be paying some attention to, rather than merely Dr. Gellar’s lady-love. Mrs. Peterssen specifically targets the detective in her plan, claiming Annie’s involvement in this matter “is of utmost importance…” She believes this will somehow “resolve the police situation during these crucial next two days,” yet she may be overconfident on this point. Annie indicates she’s not entirely convinced by the situation before her, and the fact she reveals this to Jo hints at a major intersection of the cast, the beginning of the plot’s ripening at last.
When I started typing up the credits, I kept looking for the name of the second artist who worked on the issue, the one responsible for all the flashback scenes. Yet it appears that Esquejo was the sole artistic contributor here, which, if true, tells you the kind of range he has. The exaggerated, cartoony figures in the second act look nothing like the true-to-life characters we’ve grown used to, and it makes me wonder if this affectation in the art is meant to undermine the truth of the sequence. Otherwise, why the change-up?
[Update: I have been informed that Adrian Alphona was responsible for the flashback art, so scratch pretty much everything I wrote in the last paragraph. The credits have been edited accordingly. See the first comment below.]
Conclusion: Although the switch in art styles in the middle seems a bit unnecessary, the issue still runs as smoothly as ever, answering questions and opening new ones simultaneously, maintaining the perfect balance of revelation and mystery.
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – My goodness, there’s a lot of bad parenting going on in this issue. Elle and Dane had the correct coping mechanism: run away! Run away!
– I rather like the lightless and soulless way Esquejo draws Mrs. Peterssen’s eyes. Brrr.
Grade
Conclusion