
By: Kevin Eastman & Tom Waltz (story), Andy Kuhn (art), Ronda Pattison (colors)
The Story: Sometimes you have to kill family to make family.
The Review: Let’s take a moment to bow our heads and pump our fists for the demise of the ill-conceived Ninja Turtles film. I know I’m a bit late to the game where that issue is concerned, but after all, I had to wait for this issue to release before I had an excuse to talk about it. Now that I’m no longer bound by my code of initial open-mindedness, I can finally say that the idea of removing the “Teenage” and “Mutant” parts out of the TMNT sounds just plain horrible.
It simply doesn’t make sense to, in the pursuit of making something contemporary, remove the very qualities which make it special or distinctive. All of this is to say we should be grateful to Waltz for teaming with Eastman and delivering a comic that has enormous respect for TMNT tradition and history. For older fans, it has got to be a thrill to hear Krang talking about his origins on the planet Utrom of Dimension X, battling against the “Neutrino scum” and reveling over the construction of his “Technodrome!”
On the other hand, it’s important that Eastman-Waltz keep their stories fresh, not merely tributes to stories past. One approach they’ve taken is injecting a philosophical, almost spiritual side to the turtles. Now, I’m not of a mind that you’ve got to give every story some highly involved, abstract theme that readers must extrapolate from the plot, but a little depth and thought goes a long way even in the silliest comics. Using the ASS* method to get there doesn’t seem like the most interesting tactic, though.
Eastman-Waltz should remember that their audience is, despite our choice of reading material, fairly refined folk. You can’t afford to shell out $3.99 for a comic about samurai reborn as rats without considering yourself firmly in the middle class. So while we may find a man who drunkenly beats his adult son contemptible, hardly anyone will think death is an appropriate punishment. Splinter’s moralizing about the point is thus a non-issue, and his “alternative” solution seems almost preposterously obvious.
More engaging is Splinter’s warning of the violence to come, basically preparing his mentees for lethal warfare. He doesn’t come right out and say killing Shredder will be necessary—which probably means it won’t come to that in the end—but he does want his family to be ready to defend themselves at all costs against a threat which won’t be satisfied with their survival. Splinter doesn’t rationalize the evil he’s asking them to commit to, but he does want to prove he’s made some soul-searching efforts to reach some kind of moral high ground. This is clearly anti-ASS, and Eastman-Waltz should indulge in more of it.
This series has no problem living up to its inherent sweetness, what with all the insistence on “family” in the issue. Kuhn’s art has a natural cuteness that plays very nice to that quality, especially in the way the characters have such small eyes and agile bodies. When Splinter asks Casey and April to stay for a family meeting, his earnest, beseeching eyes guarantee they won’t resist. Still, the title isn’t all warm and fuzzy, and Kuhn’s art definitely looks too kiddish from time to time.
Conclusion: What it lacks in big-screen appeal, this series makes up for with its faithfulness to detail. The creators have still only just started to break out from old formulas, however, and more effort in this respect is needed to make the title last through a new generation.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * An acronym for After School Special, a narrative technique which I hope, in typically deluded fashion, will catch on in popular lingo.
– Mention of the Neutrinos reminds me of the four swingers who livened up an episode or two of the cartoon back in the day. I don’t know why, but the idea of rebels who fight with space-cars was hugely appealing when I was a tyke.
Grade
Conclusion