![]()
By: Matt Fraction (story), David Aja (art), Matt Hollingsworth (colors)
The Story: Hawkeye confronts the worst thing about the holidays—cords and cables.
The Review: Much as I enjoy a good costumed battle, I have to confess that one of my favorite parts of a superhero series is seeing the life of the superhero out of costume. I like to see them confront problems that I encounter in my daily life—old women double-parking in front of the grocery store, phone bills, Greenpeace solicitors and Jehovah’s Witnesses at bus stops. I like knowing these characters as people with lives, not just as the roles they assume.
Fraction is the perfect person to work with this kind of material. He has a natural flair for dialogue that only rarely crosses over into Brian Bendis-like patter, and he can make any character sound down-to-earth and credible, whether in costume or no. Read any snippet in this issue and see for yourself.
Wolverine: “Oh, man speaking of—did you see the finale of ‘Dog Cops’ last night?”
Spider-Man: “So! Amazing!”
Hawkeye: “Gaah spoilers spoilers shut up.”*
What this kind of banter does is reveal the lives of the heroes we don’t see on the page. It convinces you they exist outside of the stories we read. They develop a substance independent from our entertainment needs.
Fraction goes a bit further and devotes most of the issue to Clint finally giving his civilian life some attention and putting it in some kind of order. Among other things, he deals with tangled electronics cables, pissy supers, clueless neighbors (“You’re Hawkguy.” “Eye.” “Yep.” “Eye. Eye.” “You, you. Hawkguy!”), and broken satellite dishes. It’s all breezy, fun, and even more remarkably, not cynical. Clint may not be the greatest hero ever, but he’s the most genuine and the most human. Hapless and overwhelmed he may be, but phony or edgy he is not.
Don’t worry; even with all this stuff going on in Clint’s personal life, Fraction finds a way to put the fists and arrows in action. I have no idea if this “Bro” gang is a legit antagonist or something Fraction created for the sake of this issue, but it does give this issue some weight beyond the jokes. Specifically, it calls Clint’s dedication into question, whether he has the will to actually tackle problems rather than postpone them or hope they go away. In that way, Fraction finds common ground between Clint’s life as a hero and his life as just Clint, and that’s a fairly difficult intersection for any superhero writer to achieve.
I wonder if the people who took issue with the non-linear arc on Batwoman will make the same complaints here. If they do, I respond with the same argument I made at that time: as long as the script gives you signposts of where you’re at in the story and the art remains true to the internal chronology, then you should be fine. I’ve heard a great deal about Aja’s work and it’s everything it’s reputed to be: clean and minimal, but stylish, modern, and effective. He knows how to use the space he’s given to pack a huge amount of story in one $2.99 issue, and he’s brilliant at using negative space to frame the characters, pulling all your focus onto their expressions. Hollingsworth’s colors are appropriately flat and low-key; he is to Aja what Matthew Wilson is to Cliff Chiang, another pupil of the School of Cool Sketch.
Conclusion: Ultimately, it’s a sentimental aside of an issue that underplays the emotions contained within, but that doesn’t take away from its sincerity and depth of heart.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * I do love how everyone seems obsessed with this Dog Cops show. I’m about as interested in seeing an episode of it as I was with Wendy the Werewolf Slayer in the old Young Justice days.
– I don’t often call out the letterer, but if more of them did the kind of thing Chris Eliopoulos does, then I might be persuaded to spend more time reviewing their work. This guy knows his graphic design.
Grade
Conclusion