ALL-NEW X-MEN #5

By: Brian Michael Bendis (story), Stuart  Immonen (pencils), Wade von Grawbadger & Craig Yeung (inks), Marte Gracia & Jason Keith (colors), and Cory Petit (letters)

The Story: Jean Grey enters Beast’s mind to help young Hank McCoy save old Hank McCoy.

The Review:  All-New X-Men has been by far the biggest surprise for me thus far of Marvel NOW.  Despite generally being a fan of Bendis, I didn’t have high hopes.  The last couple of years of Avengers comics have been rough and I wasn’t sold on the concept.  I found the first issue “meh,” but then as the issues went by, I found myself continually wanting more as, gradually, the book crept to the top of my stack.  There’s something inexplicably addictive about this book that has led to me devouring each issue and it’s something I’ve been trying to puzzle out for these last couple of weeks.

With this issue, I think I know what it is, finally: Bendis has nailed the “soap opera” vibe and the result is a terribly addictive comic book.  He’s managed this through a combination of excellent dialogue (which is remarkably light on his usual tics), solid character-work, and FUN character dynamics, particularly with respect to the excellent use Bendis has made of the original five X-Men.  This month, the dynamics they share with their present-day selves positively crackle.  Iceman/Iceman continues to be absolutely hilarious and watching Beast argue and debate himself is a real pleasure.  Meanwhile, Bendis does a solid job of building up the dread for the inevitable day where Warren meets…”Angel.”

Jean Grey is used fantastically as well this month, forced to grapple so much in so little time to the point of becoming emotionally and mentally overwhelmed.  It’s really strong stuff by Bendis, showing a hero who is strained in a way that goes beyond fighting the next model of Sentinel or what have you.  Jean is forced, instead, to contend with the future and it’s quite enjoyable to see her attempt to navigate the scale of such a conflict.  Through Jean, Bendis also continues to hammer home that this trip to the future is forcing these characters to grow up faster than they otherwise would and for Jean, this is doubly so given that she’s also run head-first into her own mortality.

For all this gravity, Bendis also does bring the laughs.  Iceman is great comic relief, for instance, and there’s a great moment, partially helped out by a visual gag from Immonen, where Jean points out how ludicrous it is to be a superhero in a tiny miniskirt.

Another accomplishment of Bendis this month, as in prior issues as well, is that this doesn’t just feel like a comic about the original five or a particular squad of X-Men and their adventures.  Rather, it truly does feel like the flagship book for the X-verse in general.  The scenes with Scott and the new mutants really do emphasize that.  Yet, unlike prior X-verse writers swamped by self-induced massive casts, Bendis gives us a remarkably balanced product: despite always having his eye on the big picture and the X-verse in general, this is still a very strong, character-driven read.

As for the art, well, it’s Immonen doing his thing which means sharp, polished, characterful comic art.  I especially enjoyed the dreamy, serene look he gave his dream sequences, as well as the way in which he somehow managed to draw three different Beasts in one issue: the pre-Cat Beast of the past, the feline Beast of the present, and, ultimately, the “new” Beast – an admittedly hulking and imposing look that I am as yet undecided on.  Regardless, it’s the sort of art that is just all too easy to love.

My only complaint about this issue was a scene involving Wolverine, that felt over the top, if not melodramatic, and, given his relationship with Evan/Kid Apocalypse, not in line with the character.

Conclusion:   This has officially reached the top 3 of Marvel NOW for me.

Grade: B+

-Alex Evans

Grade

Conclusion