SWEET TOOTH #40

By: Jeff Lemire (writer & artist), Jose Villarrubia & Lemire (colors), Carlos M. Mangual (letters), Gregory Lockard (assistant editor) & Mark Doyle (editor)

The Story: Jeff Lemire ends his outstanding post-apocalyptic series about a boy with antlers.

Review (with SPOILERS): Endings are hard and Jeff Lemire does a pretty solid job of wrapping up Sweet Tooth in this issue.  It’s impressive how he was able to show us the fate of all the major characters and also flesh out the broader world that we’ve come to enjoy over the last 3-4 years.  For example, I wanted to know what happened to Gus/Sweet Tooth AND whether the world eventually ran out of gasoline.  Lemire was able to scratch both of those itches for me.

I was impressed how this sad and depressing series ended on such a hopeful note!  Think about all the gut punches this series has delivered to the reader: seeing Jepperd originally betray Gus, learning that pathetic little Buddy was actually Jepperd’s son, finding out about Jepperd’s past, all the ignorant child hybrids who had been raised in cages and couldn’t even speak…  Gah–for awhile there it felt like Lemire just enjoyed twisting the knife every time we got comfortable with this series.  So, holy wow that this series ended with such optimism.  Even when we learn that the last humans have died and ceded the world to the hybrids, it seems to fresh, new and invigorating.  Gus got to live a long and mostly happy life.  He found love and had two sons (of course they would be sons) and died a content old man when Jepperd comes to take him away to Heaven (or whereever).

The main problem with this oversized finale is that it teases what might have been.  It reads a little like Lemire’s outline for what this story COULD HAVE BEEN if it had been 100 issues long.  Instead of fully fleshed out stories, we get a lot of 3 page vignettes.  It does resolve a lot of things, but it really demonstrates that this series could have been more.  I know, I know, I’ve heard the statements that this was “always supposed to be a 40 issue series” and that Lemire is getting to “tell his entire story”.  I think that’s BS.  This series went from a slow and sedate first 25 issues to fast-break pacing right about the time the New 52 kicked off at DC.  I’d speculate that DC was giving Lemire enough writing work that he couldn’t find time to draw Sweet Tooth.  They asked how quickly he could “wrap it up” and Lemire had enough integrity to insist on ~15 issues to do a nice job.  Still, this could have been a really long series.  Who wouldn’t have wanted to read the story of how Buddy became the militant young buck antagonist to Gus’s passive leadership and explore how these two guys who are basically half-brothers reflect different aspects of Jepperd, the man they both called “father”.  You just KNOW that Lemire would have killed on that story.  Instead we’re going to get Lemire writing Green Arrow which is like hiring a talented guy to stir cold soup really fast in hopes that it warms up from the friction.  My god, what is comics coming to.

The art is all what we’ve come to expect from Lemire, but there are two bonuses.  One is that Lemire colors a lot of the issue himself.  Lemire just has a special touch with his watercolors and it’s a look we don’t get to see much in comics.  The other treat is how bright Lemire’s work is.  If you’ve read much of Lemire’s writer/artist material, you know that it’s a sober and moody pile of work, so it’s pretty charming to see him give us a story that feels so hopeful.  All in all, it’s a very solid effort.  Enjoy it, because with Lemire’s newfound stardom as a writer, we may not see him do 40 issues as writer/artist every again.

Conclusion: A very strong finale to a beloved series.  The only downside is that it teases us with what might have been.  The stories in this issue could easily have been expanded to fill 100 issues.

Grade: A

– Dean Stell

Grade

Conclusion