JUSTICE LEAGUE #17

By: Geoff Johns (story), Ivan Reis & Paul Pelletier (pencils), Joe Prado, Oclair Albert, Sean Parsons (inks), Rod Reis & Nathan Eyring (colors)

The Story: Arthur has no choice but to force his brother to dry out.

The Review: Whether it’s just something clicking into place in Johns’ head or finding a story that really resonates with him, it’s pretty clear that he has finally found his groove on this series.  Not only does Throne of Atlantis give us his most viable rendering of the League yet, it also highlights all of Johns’ strengths as a writer: a sincere focus on the characters’ personal relationships, bold plot developments, and a pure joy in playing with the DC Universe.

While The Villain’s Journey was easily the most discouraging arc of this title, it did call attention to the fact that the League up to that point was nothing more than a band of superpowers who did their job together amiably enough, but without much personal investment.  The League’s run-in with the Cheetah exposed their bonds with each other a little bit, but only here, with Superman, Wonder Woman, and Batman trying to soothe Aquaman’s guilt over Atlantis’ attack, do you get the sense that these people can and will be friends.

It’s that camaraderie, more than anything else, that will keep you invested in the series over the long-term, so it’s a bit of a shame you don’t see more of it.  Instead, Johns gives more attention to the undeniable center of this story.  Nowadays, heroes experiencing guilt over the criminal actions of others is old hat and a cheap way to emphasize their own nobility.  For that reason, I could have lived without Arthur blaming himself for his brother’s attack on the surface, even if it does lead to a pretty dramatic development for him.

What I’m more interested in is the interplay between him and his brother.  Now, Orm is clearly crazed, but as we see in this issue, he is genuine in his devotion to his kingdom and his affection for his brother.  Even though it takes quite a beating before we get to that point, Orm does yield the throne willingly, and shows a protective loyalty to his brother in the final battle.  Amazingly enough, once Arthur does the “right” thing and—spoiler alert—turns Orm over to the League, the triumph of the victory does get muted by Orm’s truly dismayed and despairing reaction, and you feel, well, sort of bad for him.  Well played, Johns.

As solid as these more personal moments are, this issue is really an action extravaganza.  While the League gets plenty to do in all that, the Reserves enjoy some spotlight time as well, though without the tight-knight organization of the founders.  Even the Atom gets a chance to show she* can do what it takes both Superman and Wonder Woman to do.  If seeing the Reserves in action here only wetted your appetite for more, take comfort; Batman declares at the end of the issue, with Aquaman, Flash, and Green Lantern out of commission, that there may be room for some new members on the team, at last.

Now, an issue may be an action extravaganza in theory, but it takes a special artist to make it come to life.  Reis proves that he’s simply unstoppable given a massive, epic comic of this kind.  He spares no detail or pain in filling every single panel with as much activity as possible, even if it requires a double splash with Atlantean soldiers storming the streets of Boston in the midst of a tsunami-storm while deep-sea monsters burst out of the water and Justice League Reserves do their best to stem the tide—so to speak.  Just unbelievably gorgeous stuff, through and through.  Though Pelletier holds his own, his cartoonier art can’t help paling in comparison to the studly stuff of his co-penciller.

Conclusion: As a sample of pure pop comic bookery, this is exactly the kind of issue you’d want from the Justice League, bolstered by some tremendous art.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * It looks like this Atom is indeed a new, female character.

– As a Zatanna fan, I was very happy to see Johns take advantage of her fairly expansive powers in a spectacular but sensible way to help save the day.  “Retaw ot eci,” indeed.

Grade

Conclusion