
By: Kieron Gillen (story), Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)
The Story: It doesn’t get more humiliating than getting you and your boyfriend grounded.
The Review: I hope you’ll indulge me a moment as I engage in a bit of self-congratulation. For with Young Avengers #2, this makes my one thousandth review, about a fifth of all the reviews ever written on WCBR. At about seven hundred words each, I’ve officially surpassed the word count of War and Peace (though I think that comparison in itself proves that length alone is no sign of greatness), and the only thing I can say to properly suit the occasion is: huh.
Well, that’s quite enough of that. Let’s get back to what you’re actually interested in. While I enjoyed the debut of Young Avengers, I felt it only accomplished half of what every good first issue should. Gillen established a very compelling tone to the series with its punk rock, seize-the-day attitude, but despite the lively action, he didn’t deliver a very clear premise or direction for the title. By the end of the issue, you’d be hard-pressed to sum up what YA is all about.
After this issue, I’m not sure we get closer to that goal. That said, Gillen does tighten up the plot to give us a sense of what kind of story we’re dealing with here. Considering the history between the Avengers and Loki, it seems only appropriate that Kid Loki would be the one to drive our young heroes along their “first” adventure, and since this is the Avengers we’re talking about (albeit a spin-off version), an “intergalactic parasite” makes for a proper “first” opponent.
For an intergalactic parasite, however, this fake Ms. Altman doesn’t seem to have very lofty goals, does she? Aside from doing something wonky to Billy’s parents (it remains unclear whether they’ve been killed and replaced by goo-beings, or brainwashed and transmuted into goo-beings), she doesn’t actually do anything else to inspire much concern. Kid Loki states her goal is to sink her “teeth into fledgling powerhouses” like Wiccan, but to what end, we don’t know. I’m sure she’ll reveal the fullness of her evil in time, but for now, she’s not much more than a control freak with highly conservative values, the antithesis to our radical heroes.
In the meantime, Gillen engages in a little bit of metafictional play in the form of Ms. Altman’s “room” for Billy and Teddy, which appear on the page as comic book panels. While cute and interesting enough, the concept doesn’t really go anywhere in advancing the story or making a comment on anything. There’s no breaking of the fourth wall at any point, and in the end, the whole sequence is there solely for its visual pleasure, nothing more.
McKelvie-Norton dutifully convey every part of Gillen’s script, even the somewhat pointlessly metafictional parts with perfect shape and form. Lest you think this is all flash and glam here, make sure you notice Teddy’s anguish in the face of his not-mother’s increasing malevolence, a quiet bit of acting that McKelvie-Norton tastefully don’t overplay. And Wilson’s bright, primary colors gussy up the art without making them look too artificial. No matter how you look at it, this is high-class art, even for the Marvel standard, which is a pretty nice show of support for this teen title.
Conclusion: A solid second issue that has plenty to get you interested, although the signs of greatness remain far on the fringes.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – I must say, Billy is taking the fact that his parents have been taken over/destroyed by an entity of his own summoning rather well. Especially for someone who wound up in tears when he found out his boyfriend was out playing Spider-Man.
– And then to have to pay Kid Loki’s diner tab on top of all that. If Billy gets a paper cut after this, that’ll be the last straw, surely.
Grade
Conclusion