
By: Joe Kubert, Sam Glanzman, Brian Buniak (story & art), Paul Levitz (story)
The Story: If you need a reminder that war is bad, keep reading.
The Review: We all admittedly have things we can learn from those older and wiser than us. Still, I think we can agree that we’d be more inclined to learn them if the old and the wise didn’t use pontificating lectures as their mode of teaching so much of the time. It’s enough that they tell their stories and experiences; most of us are smart enough to understand the lessons ourselves. When they start pushing the lesson on you, that’s when you get a little more ornery.
Thus far, this mini has been pretty good about simply telling the story instead of shoving a moral into your face. Levitz reverses that trend immediately by giving us an actual history lesson, one delivered by an honest-to-goodness history teacher to his son. While the young Garret takes his dad’s points in stride, us readers feel more like the bored kids in the back of the classroom. “Farewell” may claim to feature Sgt. Rock, but you never get an actual story out of it. Even worse, the constant adulation over the war hero distracts from Garret and his dad’s appreciation for the war hero in their own family. While Kubert draws figures of war with great dignity, I can’t say he does much to enliven this rambling feature.
To your dismay, history class doesn’t end with Levitz’s “Farewell”; instead, it continues throughout Glanzman’s latest chapter of the U.S.S. Stevens. This is a real disappointment as it was previously such a dependably well-told feature. Unfortunately, for whatever reason, Glanzman chooses not to offer another interesting anecdote of life on the carrier, but rather a PowerPoint presentation on America’s involvement in WWII, particularly as it pertains to the conflict with Japan. The feature runs chronologically, with little flow or transition—not exactly random, but without thematic connection. While it shows off Glanzman’s skill and careful accuracy in drawing the past, it doesn’t do its job in making you relate to its substance.
Things return to truer storytelling with Kubert’s “The Biker,” but even here, he manages to push in a war element by making his protagonist a survivor of the war in Afghanistan, one who both physically and spiritually loses a part of himself to a suicide bomber. It’s unclear what he finds in its stead at this abandoned house he takes shelter in, especially once he discovers the grisly secrets hidden within. It’s also a problematic tale in that it essentially equates a suicide bomber to the mentally ill, but doesn’t provide much resolution or perspective beyond that.
Now that the issue has brought you down, it attempts to bring you even lower with the ever-grim “Spit.” At this point, the hardships of the sea-bound scamp don’t seem like they can get any worse, but Kubert proves you wrong by having Spit fight his bigger shipmates for a hard-won bit of scavenged leftover. With only one issue left, it’s hard to believe any happy ending can be in store for this troubled child.
Even against the angst and melancholy of the preceding features, “Angel and the Ape” fails to bring you any relieving laughter, even out of desperation. I don’t mean to sound like a comedy elitist, but where I used to (poorly) hone my satirical skills, every one of Buniak’s jokes would have elicited a pitying eye-roll. He’s clearly trying way too hard to be clever, what with his weak mockery of team racial quotas, the refrain of Angel as being “still quite feminine” despite her masculine pursuits,* and the obvious Casablanca take-off in having Angel meet Sam as he plays the piano in a café. Art-wise, every character pushes every gag way too far, practically winking their eyes as they deliver the jokes.
Conclusion: While I admittedly have appreciated the historical nature of this mini, I never meant that it should become an actual history lesson.
Grade: C
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Because graduating first in one’s class is apparently a male-dominated habit.
Grade
Conclusion