
By: Kieron Gillen (story), Jamie McKelvie & Mike Norton (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)
The Story: It’s always embarrassing when your parents catch you underage drinking in a club.
The Review: Does anyone remember Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip? You know, that NBC drama by star writer Aaron Sorkin and featuring TV royalty Matthew Perry and Bradley Whitfard as the leads? Believe it or not, when the show first premiered, it had one of the most talked-about pilots at the time. Critics and audiences were all predicting that Studio 60 was going to be the next hit show. And then the show tanked almost immediately afterward.
Now, I want to reassure you that is not happening on Young Avengers—at least not as quickly or as spectacularly (I believe for a while “H.M.S. Pinafore parody” became a byword for shudder-worthy TV). But I am alarmed to see this title, in contrast to its much-hyped debut, experiencing such a decline in direction, thought, and even coolness, which you may argue is the driving spirit of this series.
The appearance of Laufey at the end of #2 was surprising, but not completely out of place given Kid Loki’s presence and the proximity to Asgardia. But besides giving our heroes a hard time (handicapped as they are trying to prevent Loki from speaking), Laufey doesn’t actually help advance the plot, nor does he show much motivation beyond a desire to eat the youths before him. And when Miss America shows up to save the day, she too just appears, without any setup as to how she found them or why.
Only when America’s moms show up themselves do you catch on to the game at hand. But at three issues, you don’t really get a sense of the bigger stakes of this story just yet. Besides the fact that everyone’s parents has turned into controlling freaks, what else is in peril here? Surely this extradimensional parasite or whatever didn’t force its way into this universe just to drain the hope and joy of life from two hapless boys?
A more pressing question is what exactly Loki’s playing at. Clearly, the other teens are right to distrust him, but the fact of the matter is they have few options left for getting rid of this creature they’ve accidentally brought into their lives. Loki asking for a loan of Billy’s powers almost certainly means that the loan will turn into a theft at some point, and we can only imagine what he’ll do with it if he succeeds.
These are questions that can be answered at a later time, of course, provided Gillen sufficiently entertains us in the interim. Yet while you do get a few amusing moments in the issue, they don’t really have what it takes to carry the issue. I think Gillen overestimates how funny his hipness and pop culture references are, and how much they can deflect your attention from more serious points. If, for example, you’ve never watched Game of Thrones (and I haven’t—to my own disadvantage, I know), then the whole “Tyrion” page would be completely lost on you. I also can’t help finding it a little weird that Billy and Teddy seem so blasé about, you know, the fact that their parents have been replaced/possessed—especially Billy. For someone who was in tears that his boyfriend broke a vow to stop crimefighting, I find his total lack of noticeable emotion in regards to his mom and dad turned into gooey drones kind of disturbing.
There is no doubt that McKelvie has plenty of chops as an artist, especially after that much-touted opening sequence in #1. But since then, his storytelling has steadily lost its ambition and settled into more conventional territory, particularly on issues like this one, where it switches between swaths of talking-heads and short battle sequences. For all that, he still delivers some very admirable goods, especially with Wilson’s sophisticated, multi-toned coloring.
Conclusion: The title is perhaps resting a little too much on the laurels of its debut. Though a solid effort overall, it’s not quite as clever nor exciting as it thinks it is.
Grade: B-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Personally, if I was already suspicious of Loki, I probably wouldn’t be accepting free drinks on his tab, either. Kid though he is, he has all the makings of a Dateline predator in his makeup.
– I do love that the appearance of Laufey right beneath Asgardia does not seem to alarm any of its inhabitants.
Grade
Conclusion