JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK #18

By: Jeff Lemire & Ray Fawkes (story), Mikel Janin (aart), Jeromy Cox (colors)

The Story: Nothing quite like having your dad step in and show you up in your own story.

The Review: While I still think the higher-ups at DC are a bit foolish for their prejudice against recap pages (which are just practical, especially for new/late readers), they have a fairly sensible rationale for it.  I agree that readers aren’t dumb and in a lot of ways, gathering information from context is several times more valuable than having it handed to you.  But if a writer just ends up dumping all that into the front-end of the issue anyway, then what’s the point of rejecting recaps?

If nothing else, that kind of clumsy exposition signals a major red flag for the rest of the issue, especially if it takes up a two-page splash as it does in this issue.  With DC’s shortened page count, two pages is quite a lot simply to summarize the same bullet points that have been summarized in every issue before: Zee and Tim in trouble, Tim as savior, Xanadu growing old, Orchid turning monster, Constantine as an honest Abe, world going to ruin, etc.  It just seems like Lemire-Fawkes have run out of ideas and are stalling with old material as much as they can.

You can forgive those kinds of technical flaws if everything else about the issue works, and unfortunately, this one is riddled with problems on every level.  You might argue that Tim breaking down in tears as he sees the war he started spiraling out of control is a natural reaction for a kid, but this is no ordinary kid.  It’s a waste of his character and power to reduce him to your average brat (in response to Zee’s warning to hide, he snaps, “No.  They should hide from me!”), only to turn into a whiner three pages later (“Stop.  I take it back!  I don’t want this!” he cries, seeing the damage being wrought around him).

It’s also annoying that all this damage to Tim’s character is the price paid to elevate his dad into a figure of power, which is just a poor storytelling choice on Lemire-Fawkes’ part.  It takes away much of what made Tim so special in Books of Magic (and in his diminished incarnation in the DCU proper, effectively reduces him to a character of little substance at all), and it’s a pointless transformation of a character few people cared about into a deus ex machina.

And we’re supposed to believe that Constantine somehow orchestrated all this?  Lemire-Fawkes hint as much by having Tim’s dad remark to John, “If I was a suspicious man, I’d say you set this up from the start.  That you knew who I was.  And you know I wouldn’t do this if I had a choice.”  You’d be more inclined to believe it had you gotten even the barest hint that John knew more about what was going on than he let on, but even he repeatedly emphasizes he didn’t.

This seems like Lemire-Fawkes grasping to bring any kind of resolution to the arc, and they pretty much fall short at every turn.  The centuries-long conflict between the magical and technological folk of Epoch?  As good as forgotten.  We’re just to assume that Tim and his dad will work it out, somehow, especially since Vikar, the Epock guard, has seen that people with magic aren’t all bad.  And perhaps John’s blowback at Steve Trevor would have more punch if it had the weight of the whole team behind it, but it doesn’t.  When you look back on this arc, you can’t overlook just how little everyone (except Frankenstein) would up doing for the last several issues.  This isn’t a team book anymore, really; this is a Constantine-narrating-as-Frank-takes-action book.

Looking at the magical creatures versus pseudo-Gundam battle in this issue, it’s obvious that Janin has plenty of chops, but he’s always been one to emphasize spectacle over storytelling, and no matter how distraught he makes everyone look, there’s always been a lack of emotional credibility to his work.  The best that you can say about Janin is, with Cox at his side, he can deliver some fairly pretty and well-drawn imagery; it’s just not the stuff that you’ll enjoy looking over again and again.

Conclusion: Justice League Dark now has the distinction of being a title that I’ve Dropped twice in one incarnation.  As painful as the decision is this time, what with the potential of the creators onboard, it still ultimately feels like the right choice.

Grade: C-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – So I take it that Tim’s dad shortened his ears at some point, then?  Yowch.

– How does one tell a joke if one can’t lie anymore?  So when Constantine says, “I think I see a beautiful angel coming down to collect me,” in reference to Deadman, what is that saying about John, exactly?

Grade

Conclusion