
By: James Tynion IV & Scott Snyder (story), Guillem March (art), Tomev Morey (colors)
The Story: Even an undead assassin can’t catch a break from parental disapproval.
The Review: I really have credit to make sweeping statements about how fiction should be done, so there’s really no reason for you to take me seriously when I do. But I’m pretty sure that if you want to have a character star in his own ongoing, you better hope readers can get some kind of attachment to that character, or at least enjoy seeing him do his thing, otherwise it’s going to be a pretty rough uphill battle for that series. I’m ninety percent sure that’s key.
With Calvin Rose, the best thing I can say is that I don’t hate him; I just don’t like him, nor actively care about him either, really. Now that we’re past the half-year mark on this series, that’s become a real problem. Every issue you see Calvin sneaking through buildings, skirting death, tackling challenges, and yet you experience it all with this incurable distance. Tynion’s never made our hero very relatable, and with his passive personality, it’s hard to buy him as a self-determined protagonist. He’s more of a tool for better, more assertive minds to direct.
That makes him very useful for Sebastian’s purposes, of course—infinitely more so given the revelations we learn here. Considering the deep suspicion between the two men since #2, where Sebastian flat-out demonstrated no qualms about lying to get what he wants, you’re not surprised at all that—spoiler alert—the older man turns out to be the former grandmaster of the Court of Owls. Yet Calvin can’t even seem to wrap his brain around it, suggesting a trust and intimacy with Sebastian that has never been established on this series, much less earned.
It’d be easier to have more interest in Calvin if he only had more interesting things to do. Now, I know I’m an idiot if I expect a title called Talon to not be about Talons—but honestly, I don’t think I’m alone in feeling a bit tired of the endless stream of pasty-looking ninjas as opponents. Honestly, they’ve gotten old, even with Tynion-Snyder’s attempts to give each set a little bit of a new spin, like the O’Malley line of Talons, featuring grandfather, father, and son, each looking, eerily enough, the same age. Their family squabbling, centered on the youngest O’Malley’s failure to produce a son, just feels kind of silly in the context of undead assassins.*
This title also suffers from the fact that it mostly lacks any kind of internal tension. You can often see Tynion’s “twists” from a mile away. Here, he couldn’t have set up Nathaniel O’Malley’s imminent traitorship any more obviously had he tried. After all, it’d be kind of pointless for him and Calvin to have this shouting heart-to-heart about resenting the Court if Nathaniel isn’t going to turn on his employers in the end. Most problematically, the one thing that kind of keeps the suspense low on this title is the Court’s weakness as an antagonist as a whole. While they seemed a much more malevolent, almost omnipresent figure in Batman, here, they’re just timid—corporate jags with white masks. The fact that the mere mention of the Dark Knight gets them scared kind of points out the Court has little impact left as villains.
Even when there’s nothing particularly sexualized about what he’s drawing, sexiness is just the trademark of March’s art. In this case, that quality can be a good thing, giving us lush, bold characters and movements. But that kind of intensity can get pretty monotonous after a while, especially since March favors close-ups to a fault. Reading this issue can feel a bit claustrophobic at times; you never feel like there’s any space to let you appreciate what you’re looking at. Tomev adds richness and glow to March’s already full figures, making this the title the equivalent of a daytime soap in terms of lighting and hue.
Conclusion: I had my doubts about this series to begin with, and over the last six months, I’ve been given no reason to dismiss them. In Dropping this title, that makes a clean sweep for DC’s Third Wave. Here’s hoping the fourth one will be better.
Grade: C
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * I suspect this is the kind of thing that WCBR editor-in-chief Ray Hilario would find to be the ridiculous side of comics. I can’t say I disagree with him.
– It’s always a bit of a bad sign when the letterer noticeably slips up a few times in a single issue too. Dezi Sienty, it’s “bludgeoned,” not “blungeoned” (and the red, squiggly line beneath the word seems to support my opinion). Also, when you write the O’Malley grandfather as saying, “strong-w willed,” it makes him look like a stutterer, which does little to make us take him seriously.
– The one moment I did kind of enjoy in the issue is Sarah torturing the distracted Sebastian with stories about some game she’s obsessed over, one I hope never to see, much less play: “And this one is called Tinypup ‘cause he’s a little dog thing, I guess. But he evolves into a big beardy dog thing called Houndland!”
Grade
Conclusion