
By: Too many to list—check out the review.
The Story: Sit back, relax—Joe Kubert’s got a whale of a tale to tell.
The Review: Some of you may have read about a week or so earlier a much-discussed blog post from Jerry Ordway, longtime DC artist. In the post he mused on the trajectory of his career, about how, in contrast to his lauded and prolific days during the Death of Superman era of DC, he’s finding it harder and harder to get work. It’s an honest and sincere bit of personal writing, and there are no easy responses to it, but his post does offer some good food for thought.
The sad fact is that commercial art, more than any other kind of art, is subject to the whims of the audience and thus vulnerable to ever-changing popular trends. It’s not that the artist lost his skill or touch; it’s just that people’s tastes change. Whether for good or ill, everyone has a right to prefer what they prefer and seek out the new over the old. Unless an artist can reinvent himself to keep up, he is unfortunately doomed to be marginalized within his niche, and I’m afraid that’s what happened to artists like Ordway.*
Anyway, you might say that Joe Kubert suffered the same doom as Ordway, but being significantly older and wiser than Ordway, he seemed much more comfortable with this place as a respected legend and guide, if no longer a popular creator in his own right. We should all be grateful a showcase like Joe Kubert Presents exists, because it allows us to appreciate the style and character of his work without the awkward pressure of trying to make it sell. Because a story like “Spit” has very little chance of selling in this day and age, not only for its unusual content, but for its antiquated technique as well. The sudden bond between Spit and the ship cook is extremely sudden and unsold, and Spit’s decision to commit to the whaler’s life gets little build-up, if any at all. It’s an interesting story, pleasantly rendered in Kubert’s classy style, but it’s more valuable as a piece of history than a commercial property.
The storytelling in “The Ruby,” co-written by Pete Carlsson, is a step closer towards modern sensibilities with the way it opens right onto the action and continues to build tension from there. It also has a more commercial spirit in the way it draws on a popular brand, though the reference to Sargon the Sorcerer feels like a bit like a last-minute decision, and overall the tale falls short as a standalone or origin story. Henrik Jonsoon’s art in the feature demonstrates how artistic tastes have changed in comics; compared to Kubert’s delicate, etched work in “Spit,” Jonsoon’s linework is bold, with many fine details and varied textures, richly colored by Joe Panico. It’s just a more eye-catching, dynamic image, and that’s what we expect from our art nowadays.
While Joe Kubert may have wanted to use this showcase as an opportunity to expose Sam Glanzman and Brian Buniak to the world, the painful fact is there’s a reason why both men were going “unrecognized by fans and publishers alike,” as Carlsson wrote in this issue’s afterword. Much as I was often touched by Glanzman’s dignified recollections of his time on the U.S.S. Stevens, I had far less affection for his WWII history lessons, as told via captioned soundbites, and he gives us more of that kind of thing here. That kind of storytelling simply has no chance of being engaging; even the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings feel dull as a result. And if you want to see outdated comic book work, look no further than Buniak, who seems to have no taste or restraint in his choice of visual or textual gags. At one point, he gives us a double splash in which he includes running snowmen, clowns in cars, and Rockettes, all without rhyme nor reason—just chaos for the sake of chaos. Even to the very end, he pushes way too hard to sell his jokes, delivering not one, but four corny puns in a row, in reference to a lady journalist strung upon a ceiling fan: “I’ve always been one of her biggest fans. Nice to see she’s part of the revolution. This could propeller whole career. It might even help the paper’s circulation.”
In the final feature, starring Kamandi, it again takes some contemporary support to give the story some sense of freshness. With Brandon Vietti, Kubert is able to deliver the melodramatic kind of tale he seems to enjoy, blending both science fiction and the supernatural at once. Vietti’s cartoony, even kiddish, art seems to draw attention to how plain and simple the story at hand really is. What it lacks in sophistication (which Kubert’s own art probably would’ve been able to provide), it makes up for it in pure energy, particularly with Jason Wright’s hyper-vivid coloring, which feels almost overwhelming after the soft palettes used in the bulk of the issue.
Conclusion: I have never seen this series as sellable material in its own right, but rather considered it more as a retrospective on one comic book legend’s talent and influence. In that regard, this has been a most valuable project indeed.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * To be fair, I’ll use myself as a case in point. If you’ve read my reviews, you know I’ve never been much impressed by Ordway’s style, in large part because of how old-fashioned it looks. It’s cruel, perhaps, to refer to art that was thrilling readers as recently as the nineties as old-fashioned, but the span of ten, fifteen years can represent a huge jump in aesthetics. Think how The Office would look if filmed in the same manner and style as Murphy Brown.
Grade
Conclusion