MIND THE GAP #9

By: Jim McCann (story), Rodin Esquejo & Dan McDaid (art), Arif Prianto (colors)

The Story: Here there be monsters under the bed—or frightened women, whichever one.

The Review: I would’ve been more intrigued by McCann’s announcement that this would be a silent issue had it not been for the fact that Batman and Robin had such an issue last month.  That not only wears down the initial novelty of the thing; now we’re going to instinctively want to hold up the two issues side by side and see how they stack up against each other, even though they’re completely different products.  That’s our competitive nature for you.

Ultimately, Batman and Robin made better use of silence in its story and also had better reason to use it.  In depicting the aftermath of Robin’s death, silence seemed to embody the wordless grief that comes after someone dies, making the lack of text naturally profound.  Here, silence is used merely to heighten suspense—that is, where suspense already exists.  In fact, for the first half of this issue, the lack of dialogue or sound feels more happenstance than purposeful.  The only way to describe the difference is that the story in Batman and Robin needed silence, whereas Mind the Gap didn’t need sound.

The only time where silence gets put to good use is the scene where Jo—spoiler alert—finds herself trapped in Dane’s apartment as his dad, Lonnie, arrives and suffers a fatal allergic reaction (courtesy of Hoodie by the direction of Min).  In this instance, the lack of sound in the story allows you to fully appreciate Jo’s breathless fear as Lonnie collapses, spots her hiding under the bed, and crawls toward her, attempting to reach the inoculator that’s rolled into her grasp.  Even without any textual signal, you can “hear” the thumping of Jo’s heartbeat in the sequence because your own sort of takes its place.

Aside from that scene, silence may do more harm than good in this issue.  Because it’s so plot-driven, focused more on what the characters are doing than what they’re thinking, having no words to occupy you means you simply breeze over the visuals.  Batman and Robin #18 kept your attention longer by leading you steadily through Batman’s procession of mourning, giving each panel its own emotional significance, including the reactions of other characters.  Watching Jo indulge in nostalgia by herself isn’t quite as gripping, and makes for an easy, fast read.

Ultimately, Batman and Robin remained committed to its silence where this issue does not.  Once Jo plays Lonnie’s recorder, she clearly breaks the silence, making a return to wordlessness kind of silly afterward, especially since Jo is the type to muse aloud to herself after these kinds of things anyway.

None of these criticisms have anything to do with the quality of the story itself, however.  We get several important revelations here, though executed in McCann’s trademark understated, subtle style, so much so that you can easily miss it.  The letter Elle leaves behind for Dane* indicates that prior to her subway attack, she may have known more about what was happening to her than anyone: “There’s so much I’ve kept from everyone…  I don’t know if I’ll ever see you again, but everybody’s gotta die sometime, right?  Hopefully, everything will come out before then…”  We also learn that Hoodie might not be quite as malevolent as the series has made him out to be, otherwise why would he care whether Jo’s “safe” or not?

Perhaps if Esquejo had drawn the whole issue himself we would’ve had more visual detail to engage with in lieu of any words or sound from the script.  Not that McDaid is somehow deficient (because despite his cartoonier style he can draw some convincingly dramatic scenes), but the loss of color, detail, and realism combined results in a less memorable product overall.

Conclusion: An important issue credibly done by its writer and artists, but its attempt at silence seems rather lacking in execution and purpose.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Speaking of which, we’re given no indication whatsoever as to how Jo knew that letter was hidden behind the framed playbill in Dane’s apartment.  It’s like she entered the place and her Spider-senses told her about it.

Grade

Conclusion