
By: Scott Snyder (writer), Greg Capullo (pencils), Danny Miki (inks), FCO Plascencia (colors) and Comicraft (letters)
Back-up by: James Tynion, IV (writer), Alex Maleev (art), Brad Anderson (colors) and Dezi Sienty (letters)
The Story: Wait…..what is Bruca Wayne robbing a bank?
Review (with SPOILERS): I didn’t love this quite as much as the beginnings of Synder’s other Batman stories. There’s nothing really wrong with it, but when you compare it to Black Mirror, Court of Owls and Death of the Family, it’s a little hard to see how a Clayface story will be joining those all time greats. And make no mistake–those previous Snyder Batman stories are ones that DC should be able to keep in constant hardcover publication for 10+ years. They are all comics that you could hand to any friend who “wants to read a good Batman story”. In fact, I’d probably give those Snyder Batman stories as gifts before other classics like Dark Knight Rises and Year One just because they have a more modern sensibility about them.
So how is a Clayface story going to stack up to the previous entrants in the Snyder Batman Library? We’ve seen Clayface stories. They always start with some known Bat-character doing something extremely out of character and eventually Batman uses his deductive powers to discover that it wasn’t in fact Jim Gordon poisoning the Gotham Baby Formula Factory; it was good old Basil Harlo (or one of the other Clayfaces). We worry what Clayface has done with the REAL Jim Gordon (cue false drama over whether the immortal Jim Gordon is really dead this time). Then Batman fights with the muddy blob of a monster and gets his butt solidly kicked until he remembers some spray on his belt that hardens/softens Clayface and Batman wins and the missing Jim Gordon is found. Yay! Good guys win! The good guys never win in comics! Ahem….
Cynicism aside, Snyder probably (certainly?) has something clever up his sleeve. I think he is physically and mentally incapable of writing standard-fare superhero comics, so I fully expect that eventually it will become clear that Clayface is part of some larger scheme/plot. But–for now–this first issue is just a garden variety Bat-comic. The words flow more nicely (because Snyder is a better writer than the others) and it looks fabulous (because Capullo is a great visual storyteller), but those parenthicals also sum up my frustration with the issue: This creative team is an A+ student who just handed in B+ work. From other students, the teacher would be thrilled, but from Snyder and Capullo, they have the talent and credibility with the fanboys to be BOLD, and this just wasn’t bold.
There is also the lingering problem of Bruce’s melancholy over Damian’s death. We didn’t see that death in the pages of Batman and there hasn’t even been an expository section where Damian’s death is mentioned. I know that most Batman fans are reading more than just Batman, but it is still sloppy publication strategy. How would you collect this Batman story? Will the death of Damian be included as a non-sequitur? Will there be a page that says, “Batman is sad because his son died in Batman and Robin #__.” Besides the annoying crossover-y nature of this invading story arc, we also are potentially polluting an all-time classic Batman run with ephemeral and dating material. Most of Snyder’s run on Batman has been timeless stuff: It isn’t linked at all to a particular moment in time and that’s part of why it is so powerful. You don’t have to read these issues and remember, “Oh, that’s right. These stories took place during the era when Alfred grew his hair long.” These are timeless Batman stories that shouldn’t feel dated or anchored to a particular moment in time…..except for this invasion of Damian’s death. So, when you hand a friend a collection of these Batman stories in a few years, they’ll say, “What’s with Robin dying? That’s a pretty big deal, huh?” and we’ll have to say, “Not really. There have actually been multiple Robins over time and this was only one of them. He also came back to life a few months later when he was thrown in the Lazarus Pit and returned to be Batman’s arch enemy in the Attack of the Prodigal Son mega-crossover……” To be clear, Snyder is executing as well as possible given the constraints, but this Damian Death coming into Batman is like a fart in the other room coming in under the door.
Of course, the issue looks great. When I saw Danny Miki’s name on the cover, I did worry for a second because inkers like Jonathan Glapion have a much bigger impact on the visual feel of a comic than most fans realize. It IS more than just tracing and I hadn’t seen much of Miki’s work recently. I needn’t have worried. His inks over Capullo’s pencils are probably a little softer than Glapion’s, but only the most attentive fans will notice a difference.
Now, the one part of this comic that did curl my toes a little bit was the Tynion/Maleev back-up story. Not only does it feature a nifty guest starring appearance by Superman, the bad guy isn’t anyone I know anything about. ANYTHING could happen next! That’s why I generally loathe establish villains: I know what they can do and also know that they are likely to recycle. This Will O’ The Wisp is something I cannot even Google search; there is no Wikipedia entry for him. All I know is what I’ve learned in these few pages. I just know that he’s eating people, looks really nasty and is magic-based (bad news for Superman). Can’t wait to learn more about THIS.
Conclusion: From any other creative team, this issue would be cause to clap maniacally and toss the creators a fish treat! Unfortunately, Snyder and Capullo have spoiled us rotten with mindbending Bat-stories and this isn’t quite up to their lofty standards. It’s still good, but it doesn’t have that snap to it. Keep an eye on the back-up though!
Grade: B+
– Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion