
By: Paul Cornell (story), Ryan Kelly (art), Giulia Brusco (colors)
The Story: Kidd realizes he’s spent a lot of time visualizing naked people.
The Review: It’s kind of a rite of passage for every comic book fan to get attached to a series that seemingly no one else in the world even cares about, much less cares enough to love or hate, and then go through the agony of having that series taken away before its time. I’ve had the fortune to experience this multiple times, which has allowed me to get a practical perspective on the whole thing, though it doesn’t lessen the sting by much.
The cancellation of Saucer Country was announced about a month or so after I officially declared it as one of my favorite titles last year, which left me with the sneaking suspicion that I might be cursed. Oh, well. In a case like this, all you can really do is cross your fingers that you’ll at least get a somewhat satisfying finale, one that rewards the devotees for all the time and affection they’ve invested into the story and characters. To a certain extent, this issue strives to do all that, but gets hampered by the timing.
This title has built up Arcadia’s presidential campaign as an uphill battle, not just because of the whole aliens situation, but also because of the background of the candidate. The satisfaction of victory comes from the knowledge of how much work and effort it took to get there. For Arcadia, victory seems to fall right into her lap (more on that in a moment), depriving us of the fun and drama inherent in the campaign itself: the ebb and flow of public opinion, the political and rhetorical maneuvering, the scandals and gaffes that need to be fixed. We missed all of that, so Arcadia’s election loses a lot of its impact.
In the same way, this title set us up to expect a much longer, more involved investigation into America’s UFO problem than what we ended up getting. Had Kidd and Fausto discovered the true nature of the Pioneer couple after another year of dead ends and persistence, the revelations contained in the issue would have felt that much sweeter for all involved.
Cornell has always been a bit ambiguous as to whether there really is an extraterrestrial threat in this series, and while the Pioneer couple’s story explains much, it doesn’t explain everything. It’s still uncertain how much of what’s happened to Kidd was purely politically motivated or motivated by otherworldly concerns (i.e. Major Abramowitz’s involvement). And there are still a few tantalizing details left unclear: the nature of the silver woman both Kidd and Arcadia have seen, the sudden silence of Mr. Brady of the Bluebirds, the photo Astelle found of a large and bright “something” appearing over Arcadia and Michael’s car the night they were ostensibly abducted, and most of all, President Wardlow’s concession call:
“They won’t let you do what you want, you know! They won’t let you find anything out! All we are to them is…property.”
There are pretty thin threads if they’re going to lead us to some actual aliens, but the allure of the mystery is what keeps us all a little open-minded about the possibilities. For us, as for Kidd, we may be a little unwilling to admit just yet that the answers are as prosaic as they seem to be. At any rate, Cornell leaves the point open and instead encourages us to bask in one hard fact: the day when “a brown woman took power,” which should be a warning to all the white and “grey” men out there.
God bless Kelly for staying by Cornell’s side nearly every step of the way. There’s such a timeless appeal to his art, which is true to life, with all the intricate details he puts into backgrounds and props, yet never stagnates with too much realism. He also knows how to imbue every character’s expression and body with emotion so that you don’t even need text to know what’s going on. I look forward to whatever project he gets to work on next, and I hope Brusco accompanies him, because she knows how to balance liveliness with the suspense, which is just what Kelly’s soap opera figures need.
Conclusion: Had this been the thirtieth issue, this would have been a terrific finale (or better yet, a perfect mid-series climax). As is, it works pretty well, tying up some important points while leaving the future open-ended, as it should be.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Harry discovers that as far as former presidents and their knowledge of outer space visitors go, “Clinton and Carter had to ask. Reagan seemed to know.”
“That says everything,” Arcadia remarks.
“It does.”
I’m not super-political, but I do enjoy a little ribbing of Reagan, if only because he’s so much fun to tease.
Grade
Conclusion